Base game
- Platinum Obtain all other Trophies 6.3%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 39.7%Rare
- Chain Struggle Win using a Chain Struggle 61.9%Common
- Tag Chain Struggle Win using a Tag Chain Struggle 21.5%Rare
- Grapplemania Win using only grapple attacks 12.6%Very rare
- Technician Win by using five or more reversals in a single match 18.6%Rare
- Royal Rumble Winner Win a 30-Man Royal Rumble 12.7%Very rare
- Dive Attack Successfully perform a dive attack from all four corners 17.4%Rare
- First Medal Obtain a medal in WrestleMania Tour Mode 40.4%Rare
- Medal Collector Obtain all of the medals in WrestleMania Tour Mode 8.5%Very rare
- WrestleMania Tour Clear all "Relive" matches in WrestleMania Tour Mode 23.3%Rare
- Memory Serves Me Well Complete any match without pausing in the "Relive" section of WrestleMania Tour Mode 39.6%Rare
- New Legend Defeat 10 opponents with a Created Legend in a single tier in Legend Killer Mode 24.9%Rare
- Legend Killer Obtain a medal in Legend Killer Mode 24.7%Rare
- True Legend Killer Obtain all of the medals in Legend Killer Mode 9.4%Very rare
- Invincible Created Legend Max out a Created Legend's attributes 11.5%Very rare
- Super Fast Legend Killer Become a Legend Killer in Legend Killer Mode in 30 minutes or less 18.1%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 11%Very rare
- You're #1 Have your Created Legend reach the Top rank in Hall of Fame Mode 36.7%Rare
- Created a Legend Make a Created Legend 50.1%Common
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.