Base game
- PLATINUM OBTAIN ALL OTHER TROPHIES 2%Ultra rare
- Story Designer Create an original story using WWE STORY DESIGNER Mode. 6.5%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 8.3%Very rare
- 2010 Hall of Fame Nominee Induct a Superstar into the HALL OF FAME. 5.2%Very rare
- A Showman Like No Other Have a total of 20 or more 5-star rated matches in your overall match history. 13.4%Very rare
- Mickie James Story Complete the MICKIE JAMES story in ROAD TO WRESTLEMANIA mode. 16.5%Rare
- Edge Story Complete the EDGE story in ROAD TO WRESTLEMANIA mode. 21.3%Rare
- HBK Story Complete the HBK story in ROAD TO WRESTLEMANIA mode. 18.7%Rare
- Orton Story Complete the ORTON story in ROAD TO WRESTLEMANIA mode. 21.2%Rare
- Brand Warfare Story Complete the BRAND WARFARE story in ROAD TO WRESTLEMANIA mode. 22.9%Rare
- Created Superstar Story Complete the CREATE A SUPERSTAR story in ROAD TO WRESTLEMANIA mode. 23%Rare
- Nothing More to Collect Unlock all the playable characters and bonus items. 2.9%Ultra rare
- Face on the Big Screen Convert a HIGHLIGHT REEL into an entrance movie. 10.8%Very rare
- Developmental Graduate Complete the TRAINING CHECKLIST. 2.5%Ultra rare
- Career Growth Increase the overall rating of a CREATED SUPERSTAR to a 90 or above. 18.2%Rare
- Check Out the New Threads Create ALTERNATE ATTIRE for a CREATED SUPERSTAR and new THREADS for a WWE SUPERSTAR. 14.5%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 56.5%Common
- Finisher of the Year Candidate Create a dive finisher, in Create A Finisher mode, and use it in a match (single player only). 13.8%Very rare
- Ask Him Ref! Win 10 matches by submission (single player only). 13.5%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 27.2%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 16.1%Rare
- Ahead of the Pack Win as tentative Champion from start to end in CHAMPIONSHIP SCRAMBLE. (single player only) 9.2%Very rare
- Royal Rumble Specialist Win a 30-Man ROYAL RUMBLE as the first entrant without changing Superstars (single player only). 17.6%Rare
- And STILL Champion... Defend a Title in a Championship Scramble match on Legend difficulty (single player only). 4.8%Ultra rare
- Shoulders to the Mat Win 50 matches by pinfall (single player only). 24.3%Rare
- A Grappling Machine In one match, perform all 16 STRONG GRAPPLE moves on your opponent (single player only). 6.6%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.