Base game
- EP1: The Math Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 33.1%Rare
- EP1: The Logic Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 24.2%Rare
- EP1: The Fastest Answer This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold award time during the Story Mode 58.1%Common
- EP1: Case Reviewed This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions 15.5%Rare
- EP1: Sherlock Is Alive This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode 10.5%Very rare
- EP1: Mystery Solved This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit 32.3%Rare
- EP1: Made it to the end This trophy is awarded when the player finishes Episode One 41.4%Rare
- EP2: The Math Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 8%Very rare
- EP2: The Logic Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 10.4%Very rare
- EP2: The Fastest Answer This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold award time during the Story Mode 13%Very rare
- EP2: Case Reviewed This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions 6.5%Very rare
- EP2: Sherlock Is Alive This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode 4.6%Ultra rare
- EP2: Mystery Solved This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit 10.8%Very rare
- EP3: The Math Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 8.1%Very rare
- EP3: The Logic Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 6.1%Very rare
- EP3: The Fastest Answer This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold award time during the Story Mode 9.1%Very rare
- EP3: Case Reviewed This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions 5.1%Very rare
- EP3: Sherlock Is Alive This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode 4.3%Ultra rare
- EP3: Mystery Solved This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit 6.5%Very rare
- EP4: The Math Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 4.9%Ultra rare
- EP4: The Logic Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 4.6%Ultra rare
- EP4: The Fastest Answer This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold award time during the Story Mode 6.6%Very rare
- EP4: Case Reviewed This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions 4.3%Ultra rare
- EP4: Sherlock Is Alive This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode 3.9%Ultra rare
- EP4: Mystery Solved This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit 6%Very rare
- EP5: The Math Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 4.8%Ultra rare
- EP5: The Logic Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 5%Ultra rare
- EP5: The Fastest Answer This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold award time during the Story Mode 5.8%Very rare
- EP5: Case Reviewed This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions 4.4%Ultra rare
- EP5: Sherlock Is Alive This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode 3.8%Ultra rare
- EP5: Mystery Solved This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit 5.6%Very rare
- EP6: The Math Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most math-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 4.4%Ultra rare
- EP6: The Logic Master This trophy is awarded when the player earns a gold medal in the most logic-intensive puzzle of the episode during the Story Mode 5.1%Very rare
- EP6: The Fastest Answer This trophy is awarded the first time a player solves a puzzle in half of the gold award time during the Story Mode 5.8%Very rare
- EP6: Case Reviewed This trophy is awarded after the player correctly answers all the Case Review questions 4.3%Ultra rare
- EP6: Sherlock Is Alive! This trophy is awarded after the player earns a gold medal in all the puzzles during the Story Mode 3.7%Ultra rare
- EP6: Mystery Solved This trophy is awarded after the player correctly identifies the culprit 5.1%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.