Base game
- Raise Your Banner Acquire all the Bronze, Silver and Gold trophies 0.6%Ultra rare
- Custom Sweater Complete an EA SPORTS™ Hockey League match while wearing a Custom Jersey 4.1%Ultra rare
- Boosted Up Complete an EA SPORTS™ Hockey League match with any one attribute boosted by +9 1%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 21.3%Rare
- Practice, Practice, Practice Play at least 8 hours of game time in EA SPORTS™ Hockey League Practice 0.7%Ultra rare
- EASHL Playoffs Be a member of an EA SPORTS™ Hockey League team when they participate in a monthly playoff 2.1%Ultra rare
- EASHL Playoffs Champ Be a member of an EA SPORTS™ Hockey League team when they win a monthly playoff match 1.6%Ultra rare
- EASHL Sophomore Play 100 Ranked matches with your online Be A Pro character 2.4%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 44.9%Rare
- EASHL Veteran Play 250 Ranked matches with your online Be A Pro character 1.6%Ultra rare
- Boost Master Purchase or unlock 20 Boost items 10.6%Very rare
- Top Draft Pick Get your created Pro drafted in the first round of the NHL® draft 23.8%Rare
- Staying Power Remain on your NHL® team after the Pre-Season with a created Pro 25%Rare
- Filled Up Complete a Be A Pro game with all Boost Slots of one equipment type filled 2.1%Ultra rare
- Penalty Killer Kill off a 5 on 3 powerplay lasting at least 1 minute in a ranked versus match 12%Very rare
- Come Back King Win a ranked versus match starting the 3rd period down by at least 2 goals 4.8%Ultra rare
- Shootout Start Win 5 Ranked Online Shootout matches 4.5%Ultra rare
- Schooled! Play and win a Ranked Online Shootout match using a OHL, WHL or QMJHL team 2.7%Ultra rare
- Getting Started Open a Hockey Ultimate Team Starter Pack 21.5%Rare
- HUT CPU Win Play and win a Hockey Ultimate Team single player match versus at least a Pro level CPU 8.9%Very rare
- HUT Online Win Play and win a Hockey Ultimate Team online match 4.9%Ultra rare
- Jumbo Pack Open first Jumbo Pack 4.7%Ultra rare
- Looking for Deals Visit a Hockey Ultimate Team Trading screen 11.6%Very rare
- Box of Cards Open 15 Card Packs 3.8%Ultra rare
- Taking on the CPU Enter a Hockey Ultimate Team single player tournament 10.4%Very rare
- Taking on the Public Enter a Hockey Ultimate Team online tournament 3.8%Ultra rare
- One Down Win a Hockey Ultimate Team online trophy 1%Ultra rare
- HUT Playoff Contender Qualify for a Hockey Ultimate Team monthly playoff tournament 2.2%Ultra rare
- Team Colors Collect both a Logo Card and all Jersey Cards from the same team 1.1%Ultra rare
- 5 Star Battle Beat another 5 star team with your 5 star team in a Hockey Ultimate Team online match 0.7%Ultra rare
- HUT Champion Collect 5 Hockey Ultimate Team Online Trophies in your Collection 0.6%Ultra rare
- Try It On For Size Visit the Hockey Shop and equip an attribute boost into a boost slot 23.3%Rare
- Up and Comers Play and win a match using an OHL, WHL or QMJHL team against a Pro level CPU NHL® team 2.8%Ultra rare
- Good Preview Play and win a Pre-Season match in Be A GM mode 11.1%Very rare
- Proven Worth Play and complete a game while scoring a goal with a newly drafted skater in Be A GM mode 4.6%Ultra rare
- Poached Sign, from another team, a level 3 or above Restricted Free Agent in Be A GM 5.3%Very rare
- Legendary GM Receive your Legend Plaque in Be A GM using at least Medium difficulty 1.9%Ultra rare
- Sacrifice the Body Block a shot without a stick 13.6%Very rare
- Fist Pump Perform a User Controlled Goal Celebration 80.2%Common
- Faceoff Victor Play and finish a ranked versus match with a Faceoff percentage of at least 75% 8.9%Very rare
- Look Ma, No Stick Without a stick, perform a kick or glove pass that leads to a goal 14.4%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.