Base game
- Challenge of the Sphunx Completed Monsieur Papierwaite's challenge Rarity not known yet
- Looters of the Lost Toybox Successfully raided the Tomb of Sammun-Mak. Rarity not known yet
- Mystery on the Disorient Express Foiled an onboard sneak-thief. Rarity not known yet
- Horror Show Stop a seriously sinister ceremony. Rarity not known yet
- Say Hi to the Nice People, Charlie Throw your voice to every available target. Rarity not known yet
- Curse the Luck Get zapped with fewer than six Mole Curses. Rarity not known yet
- Nine Lives of Sameth & Maximus See Sameth and/or Maximus die at nine distinct points in the game. Rarity not known yet
- Chrono Logic Complete the four reels in sequential order. Rarity not known yet
- Doppel Fluch Cause German train passenger to be saddled with two curses at the same time. Rarity not known yet
- Double-Crossed Cause your little buddy to lose both his luck and his rabbithood at the same time. Rarity not known yet
- Secret Handshake Fool a Yog Soggoth devotee into thinking you’re a member of the Brotherhood. Rarity not known yet
- Open Wide Make it through the Mouth of the Sphunx the first time it opens. Rarity not known yet
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.