Base game
- The Spark Win a game 58.1%Common
- Life Preserver Increase your life total to 30 or more in single player, or 60 or more in Two-Headed Giant 35.2%Rare
- Magic: The Puzzling Complete a challenge 28.3%Rare
- Devastator Deal 20 combat damage to a player in a single turn in a game 43.7%Rare
- Defender of Foriys Win a Two-Headed Giant game 14.5%Very rare
- Spellslinger Defeat someone who has earned the Spellslinger trophy 13.3%Very rare
- Duelist Win 5 ranked PlayStation®Network matches 5.6%Very rare
- Epic Conclusion Defeat Tezzeret in the final single-player campaign battle 24.4%Rare
- Puzzling Master Complete all challenges 12.9%Very rare
- Master of Artifice Defeat Tezzeret the Seeker & Sarkhan Vol in the cooperative campaign 5.3%Very rare
- Duels Master Win 10 PlayStation®Network matches 6.9%Very rare
- Planeswalker Unlock 100% 2.4%Ultra rare
Expansion One
DLC- Dragon Slayer Defeat Nicol Bolas in the single player campaign (Duel the Dragon) 8.1%Very rare
- Overkill Control creatures with a total power of 75 or more (Duel the Dragon) 6.2%Very rare
- Puzzling Grandmaster Earn Puzzling Master and complete all Duel the Dragon expansion challenges 3.7%Ultra rare
Expansion Two
DLC- Last One Standing Win a 3- or 4-player match on PlayStation®Network 3.2%Ultra rare
- Overflowing Harvest Put 8 lands onto the battlefield in one turn 2.9%Ultra rare
- Everything at Stake Defeat Sorin Markov in the single-player campaign (Expansion 2) 6.6%Very rare
Expansion Three
DLC- Tsunami of Pain Deal 12 combat damage to an opponent in a single attack with one blue creature 3.8%Ultra rare
- Salt in the Wound An opponent's last permanent leaves the battlefield 3.5%Ultra rare
- Madness Suppressed Defeat Sarkhan the Mad in the single-player campaign (Expansion 3) 5.9%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.