Base game
-
Meals Fit for a King... Queen... Whatever
Gave the MerLeader every kind of bait
Rarity not known yet
-
She's Cute When She's Angry
Get Morgan angry by repeatedly checking out the mast
Rarity not known yet
-
Fishing for Literalists
Caught a Red Herring
Rarity not known yet
-
Talk to the Hook
Threatened a number of adversaries with a Hook
Rarity not known yet
-
Nice Try
Heard the Secret of Donkey Island
Rarity not known yet
-
Give Her a Hand
Kicked LeFlay off the Screaming Narwhal
Rarity not known yet
-
Artifacts of LIfe
Get all of the Summoning Artifacts
Rarity not known yet
-
Mighty Merperson Rescuer
Save the MerLeader from McGillicutty
Rarity not known yet
-
Model of E-FISH-Ency
Read every fish joke
Rarity not known yet
-
Ride 'Em, Pirate
Made LeChuck do something embarassing on the cliff
Rarity not known yet
-
The BIG Finish
Sailed to the alleged resting place of La Esponja Grande
Rarity not known yet
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.