Base game
- Supreme Witchslayer Fully execute your Knights Contract 5.5%Very rare
- Bone Collector Defeat the witch Straeggele 66.6%Common
- Ice Breaker Defeat the witch Trude 45.8%Rare
- Fire Fighter Defeat the witch Holda 35.2%Rare
- Until Next Time... Force Faust to retreat 34.5%Rare
- Storm Stopper Defeat the witch Trendula 28.9%Rare
- Hair Cutter Defeat the witch Rapunzel 28.5%Rare
- Stone Crusher Defeat the witch Verderinde 23.4%Rare
- To the Fires of Hell Defeat Faust 20.1%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 18.4%Rare
- Novice Executioner Beat the game on Page 18.2%Rare
- Average Executioner Beat the game on Squire 12.1%Very rare
- Skilled Executioner Beat the game on Knight 6.6%Very rare
- Master Executioner Beat the game on Hexen Knight 5.8%Very rare
- Legendary Executioner Beat the game on Witchslayer 5.6%Very rare
- The Witch's Ultimate Weapon Acquire Spirit Cannon 6.2%Very rare
- Terror Acquire the Scythe of the Assassin Queen 45.8%Rare
- Fright Acquire the Scythe of Imperial Massacre 28.5%Rare
- Soul Grabber Collect 10,000 souls 58.5%Common
- Soul Reaper Collect 100,000 souls 24.7%Rare
- Combo Master Attain the highest possible combo rating 34.9%Rare
- The Sonic Knight Perform a 30-hit combo 43.4%Rare
- Take One for the Team Perform 10 counterattacks while taking enemy attacks 27.7%Rare
- Ring Around the Rosie Catch and defeat five enemies at once with Mag Mell's Rose 11%Very rare
- Keeping Healthy Collect 100 Recovery Items 27.4%Rare
- Souls United Defeat 200 enemies with Knight's Fury 5.7%Very rare
- Her True Strength Defeat 200 enemies with Witch's Embrace 6%Very rare
- A Worthy Apprentice Defeat 50 enemies with the help of Minukelsus 23.3%Rare
- Growing Power Upgrade a Witchcraft 48.9%Rare
- Witchcraft Collector Acquire all Witchcraft 6.1%Very rare
- The Finer Things Acquire all equipment 9.7%Very rare
- Light Reading Acquire a collection item 84.6%Common
- Information Junkie Acquire all collection items 7%Very rare
- Blood Spilled Defeat an enemy 97.2%Common
- Blood Bath Defeat 100 enemies 67.6%Common
- Bloody Massacre Defeat 1,000 enemies 17.6%Rare
- Executed Land a Finisher 69.7%Common
- Skillfully Executed Land 100 Finishers 27.5%Rare
- Expertly Executed Land 1,000 Finishers 5.9%Very rare
- Elegantly Executed Land 100 Perfect Finishers 14.6%Very rare
- Head Bangin' Bash the same enemy into a wall five times 10.1%Very rare
- Get 'Em Up Pick up the same enemy five times 13.3%Very rare
- Nice Try! Repel an enemy's attack 10 times 33%Rare
- 'Tis But a Scratch! Experience your first revival 91.8%Common
- It's Just a Flesh Wound! Revive 50 times 31.1%Rare
- Bodyguard Save Gretchen from enemy attack 88.6%Common
- Guardian Knight Save Gretchen from enemy attack 50 times 20.8%Rare
- Eye Candy Use Witch's Embrace when no enemies are present 23.1%Rare
- I'm Taking You With Me Damage both yourself and an enemy with Witchcraft 31.8%Rare
- Careful With That! Damage both yourself and an enemy with Witchcraft 10 times 8.6%Very rare
- Touch Too Much Carry Gretchen around for a long time 7.7%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.