Base game
- All trophies awarded Obtain all trophies. 1.2%Ultra rare
- The New Generation Defeat a Legend with a Superstar. 64.2%Common
- Showing Them How It's Done Defeat a Superstar with a Legend. 64.6%Common
- Facing the Deadman Complete the Legends Path of Champions with any Superstar. 30.6%Rare
- The Apex Predator Complete the Superstars Path of Champions with any Superstar. 25.7%Rare
- Breaking the Rules Complete the Tag Team Path of Champions with any Superstars. 28.8%Rare
- Rising Star Complete any Path of Champions with a created Superstar. 16.6%Rare
- Old School Complete all Fantasy Warfare matches as a WWE Legend. 6.3%Very rare
- Legend Killer Complete all Fantasy Warfare matches as a WWE Superstar. 5.8%Very rare
- The Next WWE Superstar Make a created Superstar. 54.3%Common
- Reversal of Fortune Perform at least 5 grapple reversals during a match. 61.5%Common
- Chain Gang Perform a combo at least 5 moves in length. 90.5%Common
- Dominating Win a match against the CPU without losing any health. 10.7%Very rare
- Layeth the Smacketh Down! Win a match in under 2 minutes. 51.7%Common
- Five Moves of Doom Execute five signature moves in a single match. 50.4%Common
- Running Wild Perform 50 successful finishers in any mode over the course of the game. 26%Rare
- Born to Fly Perform 10 successful regular aerial moves in a single match. 47.1%Rare
- Punch Drunk Land at least 100 strikes in a single match in any mode. 51.7%Common
- Five Star Rating Achieve a five star rating in any category while facing the CPU. 69.4%Common
- Mark of Excellence Earn a gold medal in any match type while facing the CPU. 59.3%Common
- Make Them Humble Win 25 matches by knockout. 29.6%Rare
- Man of 1000 Holds Win a match without using any strikes. 22.6%Rare
- Slobberknocker Win a match without using any grapples. 26%Rare
- Over the Top Win a Steel Cage match. 54.6%Common
- In the Spotlight Win an online match. 7.7%Very rare
- Last Man Standing Win a Fatal 4 Way Elimination match. 44.1%Rare
- He's Got a Chair! Land at least 10 successful strikes with an object in a single match. 42.6%Rare
- Beating the Odds Win a Handicap match. 6.8%Very rare
- Totally Extreme! Win an Extreme Rules match. 64.7%Common
- The Champ is Here! Complete all three Path of Champions as John Cena. 3.4%Ultra rare
- The King of Kings Defeat the entire WWE All Stars roster as Triple H. 2.3%Ultra rare
- The Ultimate Achievement Defeat the entire Roster and all three Path of Champions as The Ultimate Warrior. 2.3%Ultra rare
- The Bottom Line Defeat the entire WWE All Stars roster with a single created Superstar. 3.2%Ultra rare
- Enhancement Talent Win 10 online matches. 2.5%Ultra rare
- Mid Carder Win 25 online matches. 1.8%Ultra rare
- Main Eventer Win 50 online matches. 1.6%Ultra rare
- You Can't See Me! Win 10 consecutive online matches. 1.6%Ultra rare
- The New Face of Cyberspace Defeat a created Superstar in an online match with your own created Superstar. 3.3%Ultra rare
- Suck It Win a Tornado Tag Team match as Triple H and Shawn Michaels. 10%Very rare
- Mega Powers Win a Tornado Tag Team match as Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage. 9.3%Very rare
- Comeback of the Year Win a match when your Superstar is at zero health. 67.9%Common
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 4%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 3.5%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 3.3%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 1.9%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 3.3%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.