Base game
- Soldier Win a game with Gideon's deck 74.3%Common
- Mind Sculptor Win a game with Jace's deck 49%Rare
- Vampire Win a game with Sorin’s deck 49.5%Rare
- Hot Shot Win a game with Chandra’s deck 45%Rare
- Predator Win a game with Garruk’s deck 58%Common
- Hammer Win a game with Koth’s deck 52.5%Common
- Summoner Win a game with Kiora’s deck 52.9%Common
- Artificer Win a game with Tezzeret’s deck 54.1%Common
- Dragon Win a game with Sarkhan’s deck 47.8%Rare
- Savior Win a game with Nissa’s deck 43.3%Rare
- Magic: The Puzzling Solve a Challenge 73.6%Common
- You'll Never Get Away With It Defeat an Archenemy in a game 59.7%Common
- Gather Your Allies Host an Archenemy match on PlayStation®Network with two human teammates 15.2%Rare
- Metalcraft Control three artifacts in a game 77.4%Common
- Mythic Cast a Mythic rare spell in a game 76.6%Common
- Duelist Win five matches online 25.9%Rare
- Arcane Knowledge Unlock twelve cards for one deck 66.4%Common
- Final Exam Defeat Karn in a campaign game 61.1%Common
- Puzzling Master Solve Fifteen Challenges 13.1%Very rare
- Evil's End Complete the Archenemy campaign 29.2%Rare
Expansion 1
DLC- Your Puny Minds Cannot Fathom Host a match online as the Archenemy 6.9%Very rare
- Your Fate is Thrice Sealed Win three Archenemy matches online 7.7%Very rare
- My Crushing Masterstroke Defeat Jace, Jace and Jace as the Archenemy in a campaign game 15%Very rare
- Tempest Win a game with Ral’s deck 17%Rare
- Auramancer Win a game with Ajani’s deck 20.1%Rare
- Necromancer Win a game with Liliana’s deck 21.2%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.