Base game
- Last Mage Standing Win a 3-player, 4-player, or Two-Headed Giant duel 55%Common
- Two-Headed Giant Win a Two-Headed Giant duel 42.8%Rare
- Maelstrom Wanderer Win a Planechase campaign duel 39.3%Rare
- Otherworldly Journey Win a duel online 39.8%Rare
- Jack of All Trades Unlock a card for each of ten different decks 43.1%Rare
- Archmage Unlock 30 cards for one deck 52%Common
- Praetor Slayer Solve the Say Your Praetors challenge in all five ways 14.8%Very rare
- Flawless Win a campaign duel with 20 or more life 83.2%Common
- Savor the Moment Win a campaign duel with an opponent's library empty 45.1%Rare
- Master of the Wild Hunt Win a duel controlling at least ten creatures 69.8%Common
- Beast Within Win a duel controlling a creature with at least 10 power 78.3%Common
- Dragon Slayer Defeat Nicol Bolas in the revenge campaign 35.8%Rare
- Fearless Explorer Defeat ten encounters 41%Rare
- Challenge Master Solve ten challenges 16.5%Rare
Expansion 1
DLC- Guildmage Defeat the Sepulchral Strength deck in the revenge campaign 19.5%Rare
- Auramancer Win a duel controlling at least five Auras 20%Rare
- Fury of the Horde Win a duel controlling at least twenty creatures 22.4%Rare
- Near-Death Experience Win a duel with exactly 1 life 21.9%Rare
- Insurrection Win a duel online using an expansion deck 18.5%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.