Base game
- Perfectionist Collect all the other trophies 8.5%Very rare
- Catastrophe Finish Gibbet Hill 53.2%Common
- Cataclysm Finish Between the Pages 39.6%Rare
- Helping Hand Complete your first "extra thing to do" 75.5%Common
- Papercraft Beginner Unlock your first papercraft plan 69.9%Common
- Happy Birthday Open your first Present 83.6%Common
- Crafty Create 10 Decorations with the Cutting Mat 35.9%Rare
- Too Much Swag Put more than 10 Decorations on your Messenger 48.7%Rare
- Ham-Fisted Dispatch 10 Scraps while riding the Pig 45.7%Rare
- Free Hug Throw a Gopher at a Scrap 25.3%Rare
- Dangerous Digit Dispatch 40 Scraps with your finger 52.3%Common
- Paperazzi Take 15 photos of the paper world 51.8%Common
- Tower of Doom Tumble a pile of 6 Scraps 9.3%Very rare
- Doppleganger Take a photo of the other Messenger 19.9%Rare
- Shredder Dispatch 200 Scraps 46.1%Rare
- Inspiring Presents Collect 30 presents 29%Rare
- Papercraft Enthusiast Collect 25 papercraft plans 32.4%Rare
- Humanitarian Complete 10 "extra things to do" 32.7%Rare
- Lunch Break Take a sepia photo of a Squirrel eating an acorn 11.1%Very rare
- Globe Trotter Take a photo in each Chapter 14.3%Very rare
- Good Old Days Take a black and white photo of a Gopher riding an Elk 11.7%Very rare
- Yellow Head Take a photo of Yellow Head 12.2%Very rare
- Wendigo Fissure Finish the Wendigo Fissure without losing your Stamp 9.5%Very rare
- Between the Pages Finish Between the Pages without losing your Stamp 8.9%Very rare
- Grand Tear Finish the Tear without losing your Stamp 8.8%Very rare
- You Have 1 New Message Finish the game 36.5%Rare
- Scrapped Dispatch all the Scraps 10.7%Very rare
- Gifted Collect all the hidden presents 9.4%Very rare
- Do-Gooder Complete all the "extra things to do" 10.4%Very rare
- Papercraft Wizard Collect all the papercraft plans in the world 9.7%Very rare
- Completist 100% complete the game 9.2%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.