Base game
- Epic Tale of Sorcerers Acquired all trophies. 5.6%Very rare
- Foreshadowing of Despair Fulfilled pacts of Chapter I of The Sorcerer's Ordeal. 84%Common
- Unavoidable Fate Fulfilled all pacts for The Sorcerer's Ordeal. 55.1%Common
- Greed Incarnate Knows Money Fulfilled all pacts for The Wicked Sorcerer. 32.4%Rare
- Rightful Form Fulfilled all pacts for Child of a Monster. 26.3%Rare
- Dark Mirror Fulfilled all pacts for Ballad of a Werewolf. 16.8%Rare
- The Unwavering Will Fulfilled all pacts for The Knight of Vengeance. 17%Rare
- Sorcerer's Calling Fulfilled all pacts for Several Years Later. 35.4%Rare
- Cursed Past Fulfilled all pacts for Destinies Past. 25.6%Rare
- Mad Feast Fulfilled all pacts for Fading Humanity. 21.3%Rare
- Puppet Holiday Fulfilled all pacts for Beginning of the End. 19.3%Rare
- The Fate of the World Fulfilled all pacts for Only Memories Remain. 16.4%Rare
- Bucking Fate Read through all Magusar chapters and staff credits. 12.3%Very rare
- A Brave New World Fulfilled all pacts for Innocence. 20.1%Rare
- Power of Covetousness Fulfilled all pacts for Desire. 17.2%Rare
- Something Lost, Something Gained Fulfilled all pacts for Reparation. 15.5%Rare
- Atonement Fulfilled all pacts for Atonement. 12%Very rare
- To Win at all Costs Fulfilled all pacts for Envy. 12.5%Very rare
- My Power Rules All Fulfilled all pacts for Pride. 10.8%Very rare
- Waypoint Fulfilled all pacts for Judgment. 9.8%Very rare
- The Road Traveled Fulfilled all pacts for Remorse. 8.3%Very rare
- The Jury's Perspective Fulfilled all pacts for Penitence. 6.9%Very rare
- A Better Tomorrow Fulfilled all pacts for Recursion. 6.9%Very rare
- Commanding Awe Completed all Avalon Pacts. 6.5%Very rare
- Fully-Fledged Sorcerer Defeated 10 archfiends. 24.2%Rare
- Path of a Great Sorcerer Defeated 20 archfiends. 14.2%Very rare
- Elementary Sorcerer Acquired 100 Offerings. 38%Rare
- Gradual Gain of Power Acquired 500 Offerings. 21.2%Rare
- To be Known for Greatness Acquired 1000 Offerings. 14.8%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 12.1%Very rare
- Caring for your Wares Repaired 50 Offerings. 8.9%Very rare
- Humble Beginnings Acquired one selectable raiment. 43.2%Rare
- Stylish Sorcerer Acquired 60 selectable raiments. 8.1%Very rare
- Forbidden for a Reason Learned a new Black Rite. 62.6%Common
- Last Resort, Secret Technique Learned 5 Black Rites. 15.4%Rare
- Thoughts Flow in the Arm Acquired 100 soul/life essences. 45.1%Rare
- Emotions Swirl in the Arm Acquired 1000 soul/life essences. 16.9%Rare
- Elementary Offering Fusing Fused Offerings. 45.7%Rare
- To be a Better Sorcerer Acquired 50 Offerings by fusing. 10.3%Very rare
- Without a Scratch Earn the "Unscathed Kill" award in an Avalon pact. 13.9%Very rare
- Boundless Strength Score 450 points or more in one pact. 23.4%Rare
- Boil, Torch, and Torment Inflict 5 ailments on an archfiend. 8.2%Very rare
- Light-footed Sorcerer Killed archfiend in single player mode with 1 Offering. 8.2%Very rare
- Spinner of Legends Achieve the rank of “Legendary Sorcerer” 50 times. 14.2%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 10.5%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 6.8%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 7.3%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 26.5%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 15.9%Rare
- The Path of Cooperation Relived a pact in multiplayer. 22.9%Rare
- What it Means to Fight Together Relived 20 pacts in multiplayer. 14.5%Very rare
- Sorcerer with a Swift Arm Relived 100 pacts in multiplayer. 8.8%Very rare
- Magical Milestones Visited many places on pacts. 10.5%Very rare
- Taboos should be Challenged Used a Black Rite. 57.5%Common
- I Decide Who Lives and Who Dies Life level or magic level reached 20. 25.7%Rare
- Thy Strength Runneth Over Life level or magic level reached 99. 7.2%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.