Base game
- Full Moon Earned every Trophy in every episode of The Wolf Among Us. 34.8%Rare
- Welcome to Fabletown Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 1. 79.7%Common
- Wolf in Sheriff's Clothing Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 1. 74.3%Common
- The Long Goodbye Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 1. 72.9%Common
- The Frog or the Prince? Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 1. 69.1%Common
- Panic in the Parlours Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 1. 66.3%Common
- A Light Snowfall Completed Episode 1: "Faith" 64.7%Common
- Novice Librarian Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 1. 38.7%Rare
- Right to an Attorney Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 2. 62.8%Common
- Breaking Point Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 2. 62%Common
- Sisters Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 2. 60.5%Common
- Made Them Cry Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 2. 59.8%Common
- Can I Get a Fresh Set of Towels? Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 2. 59.4%Common
- No Respect for the Dead Completed Episode 2: "Smoke and Mirrors" 59%Common
- Apprentice Librarian Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 2. 36.7%Rare
- Promising Leads Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 3. 58.6%Common
- Belly Full of Stones Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 3. 58.2%Common
- What Big Eyes You Have Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 3. 57.4%Common
- Huff and Puff Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 3. 56.7%Common
- Severe Case of Lycanthropy Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 3. 56.4%Common
- The Enchanted Land of New York City Completed Episode 3: "A Crooked Mile" 56.1%Common
- Journeyman Librarian Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 3. 35.4%Rare
- Once Upon a Time Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 4. 54.5%Common
- There Was a Wolf Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 4. 54.2%Common
- Who Ruled The Land Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 4. 53.9%Common
- He Was Much Feared Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 4. 53.7%Common
- But Soon He Mended His Evil Ways Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 4. 53.4%Common
- And All Were Happy Completed Episode 4: "In Sheep's Clothing" 53.3%Common
- Master Librarian Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 4. 37.7%Rare
- Beginning of the End Completed Chapter 1 of Episode 5. 53%Common
- This House of Straw Completed Chapter 2 of Episode 5. 52.9%Common
- A Silver Bullet Completed Chapter 3 of Episode 5. 52.3%Common
- My Last Cigarette Completed Chapter 4 of Episode 5. 52.2%Common
- The North Wind Blows Completed Chapter 5 of Episode 5. 51.9%Common
- Happily Ever After Completed Episode 5: "Cry Wolf" 51.6%Common
- Grand Master Librarian Unlocked all Book of Fables entries in Episode 5. 42.6%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.