Base game
-
Perfectionist
Collect all possible in-game trophies.
4.2%Ultra rare
-
Aye Aye, Captain!
Finish Black Peter case.
45.8%Rare
-
Off the Rails!
Finish Train case.
33.8%Rare
-
Blood and Ice
Finish Blood Bath case.
27.8%Rare
-
Vox populi, vox Dei
Finish Abbey Grange case.
25.8%Rare
-
A Deadly Flower
Finish Kew Gardens case.
22.6%Rare
-
Guilty Brotherhood
Finish Half Moon case.
20.4%Rare
-
Their Crimes, Your Punishments
Complete the game.
20.5%Rare
-
Bruiser
Beat Cairns in a fight.
15%Very rare
-
Sharpshooter
Disarm Mexican by shooting the gun from his hand.
24.6%Rare
-
Raider of the Tombs
Retrieve the Golden Knife from the ancient temple of Mithras.
28.1%Rare
-
Hold your Herrings, Captain!
Save Crocker from committing suicide.
20.9%Rare
-
Suicide is Not an Option!
Prevent Miss White from suicide.
16.2%Rare
-
Haunted House
Catch the thieves at Notting Hill Manor.
19.4%Rare
-
Child's Play!
Finish 25 mini games and puzzles without skipping.
31%Rare
-
Elementary!
Finish 35 mini games and puzzles without skipping.
27.3%Rare
-
My Grey Matters
Finish 45 mini games and puzzles without skipping.
23.5%Rare
-
I Never Guess
Reach 6 correct conclusions for all 6 cases.
12.4%Very rare
-
A Complex Mind
Reach all possible conclusions in the game.
4.3%Ultra rare
-
A Man of Character
Receive maximum personality ranking.
6.9%Very rare
-
Keen Observer
Finish 15 "Character Observations" without skipping.
29.7%Rare
-
A Methodical Man
Gather 26 Character Portraits.
18.1%Rare
-
I Never Fail
Finish 10 Dialogue QTEs without a failure.
31.9%Rare
-
An Omnivorous Reader
Receive 3 messages from those whom you condemned or absolved.
24.9%Rare
-
Dog-fancier
Interact with Toby in every case.
9.5%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.