Base game
- All Trophies Earned Earn all trophies. 0.2%Ultra rare
- The Deadman defeated WWE Universe - Defeat Undertaker at WrestleMania using a custom Superstar. 2.6%Ultra rare
- Storm out WWE Universe - Play and win 180 rivalry matches. 0.8%Ultra rare
- Mr. Money in the Bank WWE Universe - Win Money in the Bank using a custom Superstar. (Single play) 4.1%Ultra rare
- Discovering the Universe WWE Universe - Play and win 50 matches. 5.7%Very rare
- Road to WrestleMania WWE Universe - Win WrestleMania main event as the Royal Rumble winner. (Single play) 4.1%Ultra rare
- Warlords WWE Universe - Play and win WWE World Heavyweight Championship 3 times. (Single play) 6.6%Very rare
- Watch out! Successfully reverse a Finisher. (Single play) 46.1%Rare
- Comeback! Successfully perform a Comeback Move. (Single play) 32%Rare
- You can't let down your guard Successfully perform a Catching Finisher. (Single play) 24.3%Rare
- A winning combination! Use a wake-up taunt, land a Finisher, and immediately pin your opponent. (Single play) 29.4%Rare
- Excellent execution Attack every body part at least once using the limb targeting system. (Single play/Exhibition) 20.2%Rare
- Reached the ropes! Crawl to the ropes during a submission. (Single play) 17.8%Rare
- Redbox Big Moment Break the announce table with an OMG! Moment. (Single play/Exhibition) 25.2%Rare
- This is my yard! Create and play a match in at least one custom Arena. (Single play) 14.9%Very rare
- We have a winner! Win at least 20 matches on Hard difficulty or higher in Universe or Exhibition. (Single play) 3.7%Ultra rare
- Over the ropes you go! Eliminate 12 opponents with the same Superstar in a single Royal Rumble match. (Single play) 13%Very rare
- Feed me more! Win at least 50 matches on Hard difficulty or higher in Universe or Exhibition. (Single play) 2.5%Ultra rare
- Match maker Win in 20 match variations. (Single play) 8.2%Very rare
- Everybody wins! Win with 50 different Superstars. (Single play) 2.4%Ultra rare
- NXT Takeover Defeat John Cena using one of the NXT Superstars. 8.3%Very rare
- The Giant killer Beat Big Show using Rey Mysterio on Hard difficulty. (Single play) 1.8%Ultra rare
- Unknown veteran Win 10 times using a custom Superstar. 14.7%Very rare
- Tap! Tap! Tap! Make an opponent tap out with a submission that is not a Finisher or Signature move. (Single Play) 21.4%Rare
- Next Generation Who Got NXT - Complete all objectives. 5.5%Very rare
- Foundation of the future Who Got NXT - Receive a grade of A or better in Proving Ground. 1%Ultra rare
- Now that was a match! Earn 3000 points or more playing ranked matches. 0.2%Ultra rare
- A winner is you Win 50 ranked matches. 0.5%Ultra rare
- A fresh beginning Play in an Online match (Player match/Ranked match). 12.3%Very rare
- Mid-carder Reach mid-carder rank playing ranked matches. 1%Ultra rare
- One of a kind Superstar Create a custom Superstar that uses a Superstar head. 9.2%Very rare
- A creator is born Upload some kind of user created content once. 3.3%Ultra rare
- True Champion 2K Showcase - Complete "Hustle, Loyalty, Disrespect". 19.9%Rare
- The Kliq 2K Showcase - Complete "Best Friends, Bitter Enemies". 19.3%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 3.6%Ultra rare
- The beginning of a record 2K Showcase - Complete "Hustle, Loyalty, Disrespect", 11/20/11 Survivor Series on Hard or higher. 1.3%Ultra rare
- The Second City Savior 2K Showcase - Complete "Hustle, Loyalty, Disrespect", 7/17/11 Money In The Bank on Hard or higher. 1.5%Ultra rare
- Frenemies 2K Showcase - Complete "Best Friends, Bitter Enemies", 8/25/02 SummerSlam on Hard or higher. 1.6%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 19.9%Rare
- Best in the World! 2K Showcase - Beat "Hustle, Loyalty, Disrespect" on Legend difficulty. 0.8%Ultra rare
- Game over 2K Showcase - Beat "Best Friends, Bitter Enemies" on Legend difficulty. 0.8%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.