Base game
- Final Form Collect all other trophies for Jamestown+. 1.1%Ultra rare
- Veni, Vidi, Vici Survive the Super Gauntlet. 6.3%Very rare
- Bullet Heaven Survive the Gauntlet on Divine difficulty or higher. 1.2%Ultra rare
- Judgement Day Complete any mission on Judgement difficulty. 2.2%Ultra rare
- Impossible Combo Score 500,000 points with a single Vaunt combo. 2.1%Ultra rare
- No Mountain High Enough Complete the 'Partition Rings' challenge level. 1.6%Ultra rare
- No Valley Low Enough Complete the 'Luge' challenge level. 1.7%Ultra rare
- Much Vaunted Score 250,000 points with a single Vaunt combo. 8.1%Very rare
- No Miss Complete any level without dying. 17.9%Rare
- Gauntlet Runner Survive the Gauntlet on any difficulty. 18.7%Rare
- The Great Revival Revive 3 teammates at the same time with a single revive token. 6.5%Very rare
- Full Marks Complete any level with a 5-star rating. 33.7%Rare
- Vauntless Complete any level without using Vaunt. 39.6%Rare
- Centurion Card Purchase all items from the Shoppe. 1.3%Ultra rare
- A New Challenger! Complete any of the challenge levels. 30.4%Rare
- Tyrannicide Defeat the Traitor Prince. 85.3%Common
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 77.2%Common
- Ladykiller Defeat the Lady of the Lake. 70.2%Common
- Jailbreak Defeat the Dread Sentry. 64.8%Common
- Long Live the Queen Defeat the Matriarch. 47.9%Rare
- Final Destination Defeat the Last Express. 43.3%Rare
- CONQUISTADO-OR! Defeat the Conquistador. 21.2%Rare
- Rope's End Defeat the Pirate Queen. 22.3%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 15.2%Rare
DLC: Gunpowder, Treason, and Plot Pack
DLC- Fortune's Fool Survive the Gauntlet as Fortune on Legendary difficulty or higher. 1.2%Ultra rare
- Elegy for a Dead World Complete Croatoa as Ghost. 2.7%Ultra rare
- Daredevil Complete New Madrid as Gunpowder. 8%Very rare
- All of These Are Homing! Complete Dark Sector as Treason. 12.8%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.