Base game
- Final treatment Collect all trophies 0.1%Ultra rare
- Haunted Lodge survivor Finish 'Haunted Lodge' 89.1%Common
- Nightmare Descent survivor Finish 'Nightmare Descent' 73.9%Common
- Hotel Hell survivor Finish 'Hotel Hell' 52.2%Common
- Psycho Cellblock survivor Finish 'Psycho Cellblock' 38.7%Rare
- Ghost Town survivor Finish 'Ghost Town' 34%Rare
- Mines of Death survivor Finish 'Mines of Death' 27.8%Rare
- Final Inferno survivor Finish 'Final Inferno' 21.2%Rare
- Haunted Lodge killer Finish 'Haunted Lodge' on Insane 20.8%Rare
- Nightmare Descent killer Finish 'Nightmare Descent' on Insane 12.6%Very rare
- Hotel Hell killer Finish 'Hotel Hell' on Insane 5.8%Very rare
- Psycho Cellblock killer Finish 'Psycho Cellblock' on Insane 4.2%Ultra rare
- Ghost Town killer Finish 'Ghost Town' on Insane 3.4%Ultra rare
- Mines of Death killer Finish 'Mines of Death' on Insane 2.6%Ultra rare
- Final Inferno killer Finish 'Final Inferno' on Insane 1.5%Ultra rare
- Diagnosis complete Finish the story on any difficulty 16.5%Rare
- The nightmare ends Finish the story on Psychotic 0.1%Ultra rare
- Secret spotter Collect all the skittles in one level 1.4%Ultra rare
- Obsessive collector Collect all the skittles 0.2%Ultra rare
- I bestow this fire-power Pick up a new weapon 95.8%Common
- Master arsenal Have picked up all weapons 38.6%Rare
- Four barrel spray of death Dual wield Shotguns 80.3%Common
- A storm of bullets Dual wield Machine Pistols 49.4%Rare
- Do you feel lucky? Dual wield Revolvers 50.5%Common
- On a roll Reach multiplier x4 97.5%Common
- Unstoppable Reach multiplier x8 68.6%Common
- I shoot therefore I am Beat a previous set score on a level 30.4%Rare
- Barrel of laughs Kill 20 enemies with barrels 15.8%Rare
- Duck hunter Shoot all the moving ducks in 'Haunted Lodge' 57%Common
- Old school Complete a level using only pistols 0.7%Ultra rare
- Won armed Complete a level using only one hand 1.9%Ultra rare
- Blow your mind Get 100 headshots 41.2%Rare
- Mostly armless Blast off 100 limbs 53.9%Common
- Dead eye Get > 80% accuracy on a level 24.3%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 26.1%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 13.2%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 14.4%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 0.4%Ultra rare
- Nowhere to hide Hit three targets with one shot from the Revolver 33.2%Rare
- Spitting lead Hit three or more targets with a blast from the shotgun 75.6%Common
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.