Base game
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 8.8%Very rare
-
Trick Shot
Kill two enemies during one Shoot Dodge.
46%Rare
-
Four for the Price of One
Kill four enemies with one thrown grenade.
4.8%Ultra rare
-
Quickest on the Draw
Kill 10 enemies during one use of Bullet Time.
1.8%Ultra rare
-
Plenty to Go Around
Snipe 10 consecutive enemies without missing a shot.
2.8%Ultra rare
-
The American Dream
Complete Part I on any difficulty.
26%Rare
-
A Cold Day in Hell
Complete Part II on any difficulty.
19.4%Rare
-
A Bit Closer to Heaven
Complete Part III on any difficulty.
12.7%Very rare
-
Feel the Payne
Complete the game in Hard-Boiled mode.
2.2%Ultra rare
-
Under Par
Finish the game quicker than the par time of 56 minutes in New York Minute mode.
1.4%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 2.7%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.