Base game
- Tumblecrowned Earn every Tumblestone trophy. 45%Rare
- Crossing the Rubicon Complete World 1. 64.8%Common
- Stupid Lake Complete World 2. 53.3%Common
- My Darkest Hour Complete World 3. 50.5%Common
- Don't get Snooty Complete World 4. 48.7%Rare
- One Apology and Explanation Later Complete World 5. 46.7%Rare
- Mrrmmmppphhh!!! Complete World 6. 46.4%Rare
- Sausage Not Good Frozen! Complete World 7. 46.3%Rare
- Welcome to Castle Terror. No Pets Allowed Complete World 8. 46.1%Rare
- Off With His Head! Complete World 9. 45.9%Rare
- Go Deep Complete World 10. 45.6%Rare
- One Groovy Explanation Later Complete World 11. 45.5%Rare
- Thank You for a Very Enjoyable Game Complete the Story Mode. 45.2%Rare
- Orion's Belt Solve a 3-star Practice Puzzle. 48.7%Rare
- A Step in the Right Direction Solve Puzzle 2-8 using 44 moves. 45.9%Rare
- Off to the Races Win an online Puzzle Race match. 46.4%Rare
- Super Genius Win a Puzzle Race match using a modifier. 53.9%Common
- Get Rect Win an online Battle match. 45.6%Rare
- Dreamcatcher Win a Battle match against 3 Nightmare bots. 45%Rare
- Unstoppable Win an online Tug of War match. 45.6%Rare
- Fugue Win a Tug of War match against 3 Nightmare bots. 45.7%Rare
- Adrenaline Rush Get a score of 333 in Heartbeat. 45.6%Rare
- Heartbreaker Empty the board in Heartbeat. 46.1%Rare
- Deep One Get a score of 500 in Infinipuzzle. 45.7%Rare
- Deep Six Get a score of 333 in Infinipuzzle using a modifier. 45.8%Rare
- Remember the Athenians Get a score of 1,234 in Marathon. 45.7%Rare
- Toastmaster Empty the board in Marathon. 48.6%Rare
- Big Cheese Reach rank 25. 47.3%Rare
- Overachiever Complete 25 quests. 46.6%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.