Base game
- Both Sides Now Earn all the Trophies in Shadwen 8.5%Very rare
- Rotten Apples Complete Level 1: The Apple Tree 71.4%Common
- A Chance Meeting Complete Level 2: The Solitary Killer 45.1%Rare
- Through the Crypts Complete Level 3: The Way to Rivendon 34.5%Rare
- Over the Cliffside Complete Level 4: The Cliffside Fort 27.8%Rare
- Prowling the Walls Complete Level 5: The Walls of Rivendon 24.7%Rare
- Prison Rats Complete Level 6: Longwall Prison 22.6%Rare
- Past the Barracks Complete Level 7: Shortwall Barracks 21.3%Rare
- Lurking in Lowerton Complete Level 8: The Roads of Lowerton 19.2%Rare
- Across the Storages Complete Level 9: Lowerton Storages 18.2%Rare
- Working All Hours Complete Level 10: Lowerton Worksite 17.4%Rare
- The Ghost of the Harbour Complete Level 11: Rivendon Harbour 16.8%Rare
- The Night-Time Streets Complete Level 12: The Streets of Rivendon 16.2%Rare
- Uptown by Moonlight Complete Level 13: Rivendon Uptown 15.8%Rare
- The Killer in the Castle Complete Level 14: The Castle District 15.6%Rare
- The End Complete Level 15: Inside the Castle 14.8%Very rare
- Bloodstained Hands Kill all the guards in Level 2: The Solitary Killer 34.4%Rare
- The Bloodied Trail Kill all the guards in Level 3: The Way to Rivendon 15.5%Rare
- The Bloodied Fort Kill all the guards in Level 4: The Cliffside Fort 14.7%Very rare
- The Bloodied Walls Kill all the guards in Level 5: The Walls of Rivendon 13.6%Very rare
- Prison Mayhem Kill all the guards in Level 6: Longwall Prison 14.2%Very rare
- Mayhem in the Barracks Kill all the guards in Level 7: Shortwall Barracks 12.7%Very rare
- Mayhem in Lowerton Kill all the guards in Level 8: The Roads of Lowerton 12.6%Very rare
- Mayhem in the Storages Kill all the guards in Level 9: Lowerton Storages 12.6%Very rare
- Worksite Mayhem Kill all the guards in Level 10: Lowerton Worksite 11.7%Very rare
- Carnage in the Harbour Kill all the guards in Level 11: Rivendon Harbour 10.7%Very rare
- Carnage in the Streets Kill all the guards in Level 12: The Streets of Rivendon 10.8%Very rare
- Carnage in Uptown Kill all the guards in Level 13: Rivendon Uptown 11.3%Very rare
- Carnage in the Castle District Kill all the guards in Level 14: The Castle District 10.5%Very rare
- Carnage at Rivendon Castle Kill all the guards in in Level 15: Rivendon Castle 10.5%Very rare
- Keeping Calm Don't kill anyone in Level 2: The Solitary Killer 21.5%Rare
- All Calm in the Crypts Don't kill anyone in Level 3: The Way to Rivendon 15.8%Rare
- All Calm at the Fort Don't kill anyone in Level 4: The Cliffside Fort 12.5%Very rare
- All Calm at the Walls Don't kill anyone in Level 5: The Walls of Rivendon 12.1%Very rare
- All's Well at Prison Don't kill anyone in Level 6: Longwall Prison 11.6%Very rare
- All's Well at the Barracks Don't kill anyone in Level 7: Shortwall Barracks 11.4%Very rare
- All's Well in Lowerton Don't kill anyone in Level 8: The Roads of Lowerton 10.5%Very rare
- All's Well at the Storages Don't kill anyone in Level 9: Lowerton Storages 10.4%Very rare
- All's Well at the Worksite Don't kill anyone in Level 10: Lowerton Worksite 10.1%Very rare
- All Quiet at the Harbour Don't kill anyone in Level 11: Rivendon Harbour 9.9%Very rare
- All Quiet in the Streets Don't kill anyone in Level 12: The Streets of Rivendon 9.9%Very rare
- All Quiet in Uptown Don't kill anyone in Level 13: Rivendon Uptown 10%Very rare
- All Quiet in the Castle District Don't kill anyone in Level 14: The Castle District 9.8%Very rare
- All Quiet in Rivendon Castle Don't kill anyone in in Level 15: Rivendon Castle 9.8%Very rare
- Just Rewards Complete the game by leaving some or all of the guards alive, but killing the King 13.4%Very rare
- The Merciful Assassin Complete the game sparing the King's life after Lily discovers you're a killer 11.6%Very rare
- Calm and Quiet Complete the whole game without letting Lily know you're a killer 10.4%Very rare
- A Murder of Crows Complete the whole game killing all the guards and the King 9.6%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.