Base game
- TMP: Deathproof Survive The Killing Floor 3 times in one game 74.1%Common
- TMP: Feels Good to Be A-Five Answer 5 Trivia Questions in a row correctly 29.3%Rare
- TMP: Trilogy Murder Party Play 3 games in a row with the same players 34.5%Rare
- TMP: Murderithmatic Get a score of 25 or more in the Math Killing Floor 3.1%Ultra rare
- Guesspionage: Perfect Surveillance Guess the exact percentage 19.6%Rare
- Guesspionage: No More Secrets Perfect guessing of higher/lower 28.9%Rare
- Guesspionage: Top Agent Pick top three answers in final round 37.9%Rare
- Guesspionage: Live Surveillance Guess within 5% of an audience's answer 0.1%Ultra rare
- Quiplash 2: Quip it Good Get a Super Quiplash! (all player votes and 90% audience votes in a 5+ player game) 14.8%Very rare
- Quiplash 2: Quipwreck Win all your battles in Round 1, but lose all your battles in Round 2 57.3%Common
- Quiplash 2: When I Quip You Quip We Quip Create a custom game 5.5%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 0.2%Ultra rare
- Fakin' It: World's Greatest Detectives Catch the Faker on the first vote 61.6%Common
- Fakin' It: Deep Cover Faker gets through three tasks in a row without a single vote (or two tasks for three player games) 29.8%Rare
- Fakin' It: 2 Fake 2 Five-ious Play five games of Fakin' It in a row 4.3%Ultra rare
- Fakin' It: Pointilism Play 40 You Gotta Point tasks 0.1%Ultra rare
- Tee K.O.: DYE! DYE! DYE! Use all of your colors in a single drawing that then gets used on a shirt 29.8%Rare
- Tee K.O.: I FOLD Vote against your own shirt in a battle 58.9%Common
- Tee K.O.: SHIRTALITY Get all the votes in a single battle in a 5+ player game 33.3%Rare
- Tee K.O.: DOMINATION Be the creator of every shirt in the final gauntlet 8.4%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.