Base game
- Platinum Trophy Acquire all trophies Rarity not known yet
- Ascensitive Nature Took the Opto Test as Romana Teague and qualified as Ascensitive. Rarity not known yet
- Unworthy Took the Opto Test as Romana Teague, but deemed unqualified. Rarity not known yet
- In the Dark Took the Opto Test as Romana Teague and qualified as Dark Matter. Rarity not known yet
- Unwanted Took the Opto Test as Jack Bellet, but deemed unqualified. Rarity not known yet
- Ascensitized Took the Opto Test as Jack Bellet and qualified as Ascensitive. Rarity not known yet
- Making it Matter Took the Opto Test as Jack Bellet and qualified as Dark Matter Rarity not known yet
- Newshound Collect three arrest reports from Cypress Knee Police Department website. Rarity not known yet
- NSA Pet Collect three emails from Tag Kern’s tablet computer. Rarity not known yet
- Dear Diary Collect four journal entries from Tag Kern’s tablet computer. Rarity not known yet
- She's So Unusual Give consistently strange responses as Romana. Rarity not known yet
- All in the Family Post an article that includes the Aunt Mom and Uncle Dad story. Rarity not known yet
- Penny Pincher Post an article that includes the quarterback and the penny presser. Rarity not known yet
- Travellin' Roots Post an article that includes the Irish Travellers foundation. Rarity not known yet
- Ultimate Misanthrope Give consistently belligerent responses as Bellet. Rarity not known yet
- Armored Gumshoe Give consistently cynical responses as Gaddis. Rarity not known yet
- Extremist Post nothing but inflammatory reports. Rarity not known yet
- Playing It Safe Post nothing but cautious reports. Rarity not known yet
- Down the Middle Post nothing but edgy reports. Rarity not known yet
- New Girl Finish the first three scenes as Romana. Rarity not known yet
- Hometown News Finish scenes 4 and 5 as Bellet. Rarity not known yet
- On the Case Finish scenes 6 and 7 as Gaddis. Rarity not known yet
- Ferreting Out the Facts Complete Scene 8. Rarity not known yet
- Wonderland Finish Knee Deep, Act 1. Rarity not known yet
- Bring Out Your Dead K.C. Gaddis makes a grim discovery on a swampy roadside. Rarity not known yet
- Blogged Down Romana Teague faces an uncertain future. Rarity not known yet
- Paper Boy Jack Bellet’s career is in jeopardy. Rarity not known yet
- That's a Wrap K.C. Gaddis hits a rough patch as a freelance investigator. Rarity not known yet
- Dunk Of Doom It’s all fun and games until someone gets electrocuted. Rarity not known yet
- Festival Successfully complete Act 2 - Festival. Rarity not known yet
- Inherent Noir K.C. Gaddis gave lots of cynical responses during all three acts of Knee Deep. Rarity not known yet
- Swamp Oddity Romana Teague gave lots of strange responses during all three acts of Knee Deep. Rarity not known yet
- Raging Bellet Jack Bellet gave lots of belligerent responses during all three acts of Knee Deep. Rarity not known yet
- Stop the Signal Jefferson Dean Gallant successfully killed the transmission from WCKN-AM. Rarity not known yet
- Shacking Up Romana persuades her cohorts to stay at Gallant's shack. Rarity not known yet
- Swamped Romana persuades her cohorts to leave Gallant's shack. Rarity not known yet
- No Blood Woodstep walks away from Monique's house uninjured. Rarity not known yet
- Man Down Woodstep gets shot at Monique's house. Rarity not known yet
- Mad Science Unleashed The secret project in the Church of Us facility is revealed. Rarity not known yet
- Appetizer Merle the gator enjoys a snack. Rarity not known yet
- Vendetta Ends Jefferson Dean Gallant finds long-sought vengeance. Rarity not known yet
- Chuck Checks Out Chuck Chichester checks out at the Mohawk Inn. Rarity not known yet
- Chuck Walks Away Chuck Chichester walks away from Cypress Knee. Rarity not known yet
- Boomtown Successfully completed Knee Deep Act 3: Boomtown. Rarity not known yet
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.