Base game
- SMB2 Hall of Fame Obtain all trophies. 0.5%Ultra rare
- Ode to the Longballo Hit a homerun. 89.4%Common
- Good Wood Make contact with a 95+ score power swing at least five times in a single game against the CPU. 39.8%Rare
- Dirty Stuff Throw a 95+ score power pitch at least five times in a single game against the CPU. 10.9%Very rare
- Roll It Up Get two outs on the same play against the CPU.\ 66.2%Common
- Flashing the Leather Make an out with a diving catch. 60.5%Common
- Hangin' In There Foul-off four pitches with a two-strike count against the CPU. 28.6%Rare
- Defensive Meltdown Witness the opposing team make two errors in a single inning. 16.3%Rare
- Golden Sombrero Strikeout 4 times in a single game with a single player. 6.3%Very rare
- Gotta Look Good to Play Good Edit a team logo. 44.5%Rare
- I'll Keep It Fair, Trust Me While editing a Custom team, increase all of one player's skills to 99. 11.2%Very rare
- Quadinger Hit a homerun with the bases loaded. 53.4%Common
- Keep 'em Guessing Throw at least one pitch of each pitch type in a single game. 5.1%Very rare
- We're Back In This Overcome a 5-run deficit for a win in a Season or Elimination game. 17.8%Rare
- Just Give Up Already Reach a 10-run lead in a Season or Elimination game. 51.5%Common
- Tourist Win a game in every stadium. 18%Rare
- No You Don't Throw out a CPU-controlled runner while they're attempting to steal a base. 33%Rare
- Jack Attack Hit four homeruns in a row against the CPU. 11.5%Very rare
- Get a Real Hit Next Time Get a base hit with a bunt while playing against the CPU. 13.3%Very rare
- I Just Need One Pinch hit with a full count and then hit a homerun against the CPU. 0.9%Ultra rare
- Unconcealed Weapon Steal a base on the first pitch after bringing in a pinch runner against the CPU. 4.4%Ultra rare
- Repeat Offender Have a single runner steal both second and third base in the same inning against the CPU. 16.5%Rare
- Gettin' Around Have your entire lineup make a plate appearance in a single inning against the CPU. 66.4%Common
- Fun, Fun, Without a Run Have a player with 6 RBIs but no runs in a single game against the CPU. 1.4%Ultra rare
- Whiff Wizard Strike out 15 batters in one game with a single pitcher against the CPU. 12.1%Very rare
- A Touch of Clutch Win a game with a walk-off homerun using an "On Fire" or "Jacked" player against the CPU. 7.6%Very rare
- Termination by Intimidation Win a game by striking out an opposing "Rattled" player against the CPU. 11.4%Very rare
- Travel by Cycle Hit a single, double, triple, and homerun with the same player in a Season or Elimination game. 23.8%Rare
- Lookin' Demoralized Throw a called 3rd strike for the 3rd out with the bases loaded in a Season or Elimination game. 11.5%Very rare
- Pennant Tenant Make it to the playoffs in a Season of any length. 19.9%Rare
- Bracket Boss Win the championship of a Standard Elimination. 4%Ultra rare
- Tailored Tourney Titan Win the championship of a Custom Elimination. 3.9%Ultra rare
- Put a Ring on It Win the championship of a Standard Season. 7.2%Very rare
- Cream of the Custom Win the championship of a Custom Season. 10.1%Very rare
- Distinguished Dinger Hit a 500+ foot homerun. 14%Very rare
- Your Bagel, Sir Pitch a 9+ inning complete-game shutout in a Standard Season or Standard Elimination game. 16.6%Rare
- Battaire Extraordinaire Tally a regular season batting average over .400 with a player on your team (60+ plate appearances). 15.2%Rare
- Pitchaire Extraordinaire Tally a regular season ERA under 1.50 with a pitcher on your team (30+ innings pitched). 5.9%Very rare
- Knight of Knocks Hit a total of 500 hits. 27.6%Rare
- Workhorse Pitch 10 complete-game wins against the CPU (9+ inning games only). 12.4%Very rare
- Perfecto Pitch a 9+ inning complete-game perfect game in Season or Elimination mode. 4.2%Ultra rare
- SMB2 Master Win the championship of a Standard Season with a season average Ego of 80 or higher. 0.8%Ultra rare
- #Ego99 Challenge Win a 9+ inning game against the CPU at Ego 99 where both teams are Standard teams. 0.6%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.
