Base game
- Everything Ends Finish all stories 48.4%Rare
- A Closer Look Look in all peepholes and telescopes long enough to hear Edith's commentary 20.7%Rare
- All Roads Take both paths to the house 23%Rare
- Great Owl Catch 2 rabbits with only 2 swoops 19.4%Rare
- Let Him Finish Let the drunken sailor finish his song 12.6%Very rare
- Clear the Table Clear all balls off the pool table 14.9%Very rare
- G-R-E-G-O-R-Y Knock all the letters of Gregory's name into the bathtub 24.2%Rare
- Thanks, Johann! See Johann's name in the ending credits 50.1%Common
- Loop-de-loop-de-loop Play Calvin's story again 15.9%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.