Base game
- Player of the Year Collect all trophies. 11.8%Very rare
- Part 1 Begin Part One. 96.7%Common
- Part 2 Begin Part Two. 93.9%Common
- *Beephole* Complete Ransome's Flashback. 74.3%Common
- Out Of The Will Complete Delores's Flashback. 66.5%Common
- Part 3 Begin Part Three. 60.5%Common
- Secret Meeting Complete Franklin's Flashback. 58.5%Common
- Justice Catch the killer. 51.1%Common
- Part 4 Begin Part Four. 51.1%Common
- Sky High Get an alive character into the Hotel penthouse. 48.1%Rare
- Part 5 Begin Part Five. 47%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 47%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 44.9%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 44.1%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 43.8%Rare
- Easy Win Complete the game in casual mode. 21.6%Rare
- Hard Won Complete the game in hard mode. 34.4%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 39.8%Rare
- Great Escape Escape from the sewers. 61.8%Common
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 42.5%Rare
- Dust Appreciator Collect 25 specks of dust. 52.4%Common
- Book Worm Read 100 books in the library. 17.8%Rare
- Well Informed Read all the Thimbleweed Nickel newspapers. 21.4%Rare
- Hotel Tourist Visit every floor in the hotel. 36.4%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 45.7%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 37%Rare
- Dust Collector Collect 50 specks of dust. 38.3%Rare
- No One Is Home Listen to 100 Voicemail messages. 14.1%Very rare
- Mean Person Make everyone cry about their life. 17.9%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 24.6%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 16%Rare
- Dust Hoarder Collect 75 specks of dust. 22%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 17.7%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 12.9%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.