Base game
- Scribblenauts Superstar! Unlock all other trophies. 1.3%Ultra rare
- Magical Globe for Rent Bring 3 Starites to Lily and unlock the world map. 50.8%Common
- Patches and his Kite Bring 8 Starites to Lily. 29.1%Rare
- Rex the Dinosaur Hunter Bring 12 Starites to Lily. 23.6%Rare
- Yarrr, matey! Bring 16 Starites to Lily. 20.4%Rare
- Chillin’ with Chilly Bring 24 Starites to Lily. 16.2%Rare
- Tony and the Outlaw Bring 30 Starites to Lily. 13.9%Very rare
- Bubbles’ Magical Aquatic Adventure Bring 40 Starites to Lily. 11.4%Very rare
- Buzzing to the Stars Bring 50 Starites to Lily. 9.9%Very rare
- Sister Savior Bring 60 Starites to Lily. 8.7%Very rare
- Cars, Trains, and Planes Get all object Shards in the Vehicle category. 2.8%Ultra rare
- Fashion Statement Get all object Shards in the Clothes category. 2.6%Ultra rare
- Food Fight Get all object Shards in the Food category. 2.9%Ultra rare
- Fun with Weapons Get all object Shards in the Weapon category. 2.6%Ultra rare
- Jamming Out Get all object Shards in the Music category. 2.7%Ultra rare
- Living Large Get all object Shards in the Living category. 3.1%Ultra rare
- Playing with Gadgets Get all object Shards in the Tech category. 2.6%Ultra rare
- The Kitchen Sink Get all object Shards in the Misc category. 2.5%Ultra rare
- Notepad Explorer Get all 217 object Shards! 2.5%Ultra rare
- Make it Yours Edit an object or an Avatar in Scribblenauts Unlimited. 28.1%Rare
- Maxwell in Disguise Change your Avatar in Scribblenauts Unlimited. 32.3%Rare
- Helping Hand Get all the Starites in any level. 34.6%Rare
- Brotherly Love Help all 40 of Maxwell’s brothers. 4.7%Ultra rare
- Starite Get! Get all 112 Starites in Scribblenauts Unlimited! 2.4%Ultra rare
- New Skin Unlock your first costume. 9.4%Very rare
- Walk-In Closet Unlock all costumes! 1.4%Ultra rare
- Feat of Feats Complete 400 heroic feats. 1.7%Ultra rare
- Forging Justice Edit an object or an Avatar in Scribblenauts Unmasked. 12.2%Very rare
- Gotham Baller Get 3000 amount of Gotham reputation. 4.2%Ultra rare
- Kind of a Big Deal Get 3000 amount of Justice League reputation. 3.8%Ultra rare
- Super Popular Get 3000 amount of Metropolis reputation. 3.6%Ultra rare
- Meet Arthur Curry Complete Aquaman's origin mission. 2.2%Ultra rare
- Meet Barry Allen Complete Flash's origin mission. 2.7%Ultra rare
- Meet Bruce Wayne Complete Batman's origin mission. 3.8%Ultra rare
- Meet Diana Prince Complete Wonder Woman's origin mission. 2.3%Ultra rare
- Meet Hal Jordan Complete Green Lantern's origin mission. 2.4%Ultra rare
- Meet Kal-El Complete Superman's origin mission. 3.2%Ultra rare
- Not Your Normal Aquaman Spawn an alternate version of Aquaman. 6.7%Very rare
- Not Your Normal Batman Spawn an alternate version of Batman. 16.9%Rare
- Not Your Normal Cyborg Spawn an alternate version of Cyborg. 6.3%Very rare
- Not Your Normal Flash Spawn an alternate version of Flash. 8.3%Very rare
- Not Your Normal Green Lantern Spawn an alternate version of Green Lantern. 6.2%Very rare
- Not Your Normal Martian Manhunter Spawn an alternate version of Martian Manhunter. 3.7%Ultra rare
- Not Your Normal Superman Spawn an alternate version of Superman. 10.2%Very rare
- Not Your Normal Wonder Woman Spawn an alternate version of Wonder Woman. 7.8%Very rare
- No Evil Shall Escape My Sight Spawn 150 different Green Lanterns. 1.6%Ultra rare
- Honorary Superhero Complete the final mission in Scribblenauts Unmasked! 2.6%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.