Base game
- Ego te absolvo All trophies earned 13.6%Very rare
- Bloodless Victory Use your brain to win over an enemy 74.1%Common
- Spider Smasher Kill some spiders in the name of the Lord 69.2%Common
- Rest well Bring the first zombie back to the grave 64.5%Common
- Love Doctor Remove the ghost threat from the library 37.4%Rare
- The Player Try an epic board game 42.2%Rare
- Mirror mirror Enter the first mirror world 37.7%Rare
- Clean carpet Solve the carpet puzzle 34%Rare
- Joust master Finish the animated Armor 30.9%Rare
- Reflections Banish the horror back to its realm 30.5%Rare
- Doubletap Two headshots in a row 25.4%Rare
- Face to face Meet Benedictus for the first time 29.5%Rare
- Just In time Solve the clock puzzle 26.6%Rare
- Vase Runner Solve the vase puzzle 28.6%Rare
- Redeemer Empty the flask of angel tears 28.7%Rare
- Quiet Dinner Clean up the dining room 23.4%Rare
- Ghost buster Banish the hall monster 22.9%Rare
- Dead Silence Find a secret passage 19.5%Rare
- Sinner Drink from the tainted well five times 26.2%Rare
- Bookworm Find a hidden book 27.8%Rare
- Master detective Help out the ghost detective 26.1%Rare
- Good boi Trap the skull dog 24.9%Rare
- Jailbird Clear up the cellar prison cells 25.4%Rare
- Lore master Find all the scrolls of Ramirez 36.4%Rare
- Pianist Open the way with music 23.7%Rare
- Master chef Get rid of the Dumpling 23.1%Rare
- The Punisher Kill five enemies with a melee weapon 49.3%Rare
- Mirror master Visit all the mirror worlds 13.6%Very rare
- Alpinist Reach the roof 22.8%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.