Base game
- Platinum Unlock all other trophies 30.7%Rare
- Sailor Collect a gold star 95.3%Common
- Undersea Bee Hive Complete all Waspfish levels 39.5%Rare
- Evicted Fish Complete all Housekeeper levels 33%Rare
- Sniper Fish Complete all Perfect Mode levels 33.4%Rare
- Ship Mate Collect 10 gold stars 83.2%Common
- Lieutenant Collect 30 gold stars 54.7%Common
- Captain Collect 50 gold stars 44%Rare
- Admiral Collect 100 gold stars 34.3%Rare
- Golden Waspfish Collect all the stars in the Waspfish levels 34.3%Rare
- Golden HouseKeeper Collect all the stars in the Housekeeper levels 30.9%Rare
- Break on through Pass through 4 rocks with the red anchor 62.2%Common
- Kebab Destroy 2 eels with the red anchor 47.6%Rare
- Full Speed Ahead! Complete 5 levels within the time set 73.9%Common
- Bowline Complete 5 levels using the given number of knots or less 79.7%Common
- Bounty Hunter Complete 5 levels collecting all the coins 70.4%Common
- Ride of the Valkiries Catch the fish while being attacked by jellyfish 37.4%Rare
- Fisherman of the year Earn 100,000 points 40.6%Rare
- A beginner's guide to the sea Read all the scrolls 35.6%Rare
- Guided by the stars Complete 2 consecutive levels with 3 stars 65.4%Common
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.