Base game
- Employee of the Year! Congratulations on this prestigious award. You did a great job helping out PAH Inc. and you deserve it. 0.1%Ultra rare
- Start a fire! Start a fire in the boiler. 45.3%Rare
- Burn a Doll Burn a darkness doll in the boiler. 48.6%Rare
- Wrong Doll Burn a Pacify doll in the boiler. 19.3%Rare
- Key Master Collect all keys in single player or cooperative mode. 10.3%Very rare
- Key Hoarder Hold all the keys at once in player versus player mode. 0.9%Ultra rare
- Pacify Her Give the girl a doll when she is a monster. 15.7%Rare
- I love lore! Read all notes. 0.3%Ultra rare
- Bully Push someone down in player versus player. 9.7%Very rare
- You are a doll. Get attacked by the girl. 64.6%Common
- One Man Team Win the game in single player mode. 0.3%Ultra rare
- Win with Friends Win the game in cooperative mode. 28.3%Rare
- Destroy the competition. Win the game in player versus player mode. 1.6%Ultra rare
- Save a friend Give the girl a pacify doll while she is attacking a player. 7.6%Very rare
- Revive yourself Burn yourself in the boiler and become normal again. 38.5%Rare
- Beat the game developer Win a single player session in under 20 minutes. 0.2%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 2.1%Ultra rare
- Chicken Hunter Knockout a chicken on the farm. 43.4%Rare
- Fill it up Use the water trough on the farm. 36.6%Rare
- Poison the Water Use a bag of poison in the trough on the farm. 34.4%Rare
- Seasoned Chicken Dunk a chicken in the poisoned water. 34.6%Rare
- Weaken The Monster Feed the farm monster a poisoned chicken. 14.2%Very rare
- Yummy Chicken Feed the farm monster a chicken. 15%Very rare
- Interesting Story Read all of the notes on the farm. 0.6%Ultra rare
- Heavy Load Pick up the farm monster with the wheel barrow. 10.5%Very rare
- Magical Windmill Get revived in the windmill. 29.1%Rare
- Rusty Old Locks Break open all of the locks on the farm. 1.2%Ultra rare
- Farm Solo Dare to play on the farm alone. 8.9%Very rare
- Cooped up on the farm! Play on the farm in cooperative mode. 50.8%Common
- Free For All Farm Play on the farm in player versus player mode. 4.2%Ultra rare
- Beat the Game Developer II Win a single player session on the farm in under 30 minutes. 0.3%Ultra rare
- Explore The Creepy Woods Together Play in the woods in cooperative mode. 34.2%Rare
- Who Cares About The Team Play in the woods in player versus player mode. 0.9%Ultra rare
- Only You And The Witch Be fearless and play in the woods all alone. 3.9%Ultra rare
- Witch's Brew Combine the ingredients in the cauldron. 30.4%Rare
- Release The Power Impale an enchanted doll of twigs. 29.3%Rare
- Poor Puppy Snip off the tail of a puppy. 36.8%Rare
- Work From Home Find the witch's lair. 40.2%Rare
- Capture The Witch! Weaken the witch and bring her to the van in the woods. 14.2%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 2.9%Ultra rare
- Beat the Game Developer III Win a single player session in the woods in under 20 minutes. 0.1%Ultra rare
- Notes From a Lost Child Read all of the notes from the lost child in the woods. 0.3%Ultra rare
- Welcome to PAH HQ Help at the headquarters during the power outage in cooperative mode. 0.4%Ultra rare
- You Can Do It! Take on the headquarters during the power outage all by yourself. 0.1%Ultra rare
- Power it up Place a charged battery in a battery socket. 42.4%Rare
- Charge it Charge a battery to full. 28.7%Rare
- Creepy Experience Solve the haunted simulation. 14.7%Very rare
- Don't Do That Let a monster out of its cell, yourself. 7.5%Very rare
- Get back in there! Power the Lesser Containment Unit. 1.9%Ultra rare
- Self Destruct Run out of time during the self destruct sequence. 13.9%Very rare
- Invincible Don't get hurt once, while keeping the headquarters safe. 0.1%Ultra rare
- Bull's Eye Get a bullseye on the dart board. 6.5%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 0.8%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.