Base game
- One Life Guy Get every trophy. 3.9%Ultra rare
- Yellow Brick Road Complete the first quest. 85.2%Common
- Gotta Catch 'Em All! Catch all horses for This Neigh Land. 4.3%Ultra rare
- Multi-Level Manhandling Complete all quests for the Loan Shark. 33.3%Rare
- Black Sabbath Complete all quests for the Priest. 29.7%Rare
- The Last Crusade Complete all quests for the Knights of the Holy Grail. 28.9%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 18.2%Rare
- Hail to the King! Complete the main story line. 12.9%Very rare
- Blue Blood Collect 5000 gold pieces and finish "Meat Muffins" 30.9%Rare
- Weapon Master Wield all weapons available in the game at least once. 10.3%Very rare
- Most Wanted Gain and then remove a maximum Wanted rating without dying and with no quest active. 6.5%Very rare
- One Guy Army Survive for 5 minutes at maximum Wanted rating. 7.6%Very rare
- Udder Chaos Kill an NPC with a cow. 8.2%Very rare
- Groovy! Set the amount of blood particles in settings to x5 and attack someone. 31.6%Rare
- Harvest Moon Plow the fields 10 times. 5.6%Very rare
- KILLUS MAGNUS Kill 5 NPC in 5 seconds. 11.5%Very rare
- The Forel Method Block 10 attacks in 60 seconds. 11.9%Very rare
- Highway Star Come first in 10 races. 6.7%Very rare
- Invasion of the Body Snatchers Collect 20 bodies during the body collecting side activity. 5.8%Very rare
- The Ecstasy of Gold Collect 20000 gold pieces. 17.2%Rare
- Call Me Conor Win 10 fights in the MMA side activity. 12%Very rare
- One man's junk is another man's treasure Collect all horseshoes. 6.6%Very rare
- Cutthroat Kill 500 people. 6.9%Very rare
- The Other Son of Man Herd a total of 50 NPCs to mass during the church herding side activity. 7.6%Very rare
- Lowrider Use Pimp-A-Horse 20 times. 8.2%Very rare
- The Crown Complete 100% of the game, including all quests, side activities, and obtaining every other non-Platinum trophy. 3.9%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.
