Base game
- Completed All You completed all trophies. 1.5%Ultra rare
- Geezer pleaser Geezers are people too, and you treated them all with the respect they deserved. 20.7%Rare
- Sins of our fathers For better or for worse, you shattered the innocence of the youth. 11.1%Very rare
- Badge of honour You let lil' Henry hold your detective's badge. Good for you! 15%Very rare
- Keep the hope alive Reassured Florence about the fate of her daughter, Rose. 30.7%Rare
- Affirming flame Life is harsh, but you didn't let that stop you from being compassionate when it mattered. 13.2%Very rare
- Me time You chose to spend your time under the Bridge in quiet reflection. 3.4%Ultra rare
- First trust You decided to let your walls down and trust Renee from the start. 23.1%Rare
- Not born yesterday You decided to remain skeptical of Renee until she earned your loyalty. 12.9%Very rare
- True connection You felt a true connection to Renee, and acted on it. 3.2%Ultra rare
- Bad medicine You lost your patience with Louis and walked all over him. 9.8%Very rare
- Tonic for the soul You did your best to reassure Louis. 36%Rare
- Howard Lotor You introduced yourself to everyone honestly. You are who you are. 2.7%Ultra rare
- Wallace Brotor You might be a sneaky liar, but at least you kept the story straight about your alias. 3.6%Ultra rare
- Brollace Howtor Your identity fluctuated throughout the investigation. 7.7%Very rare
- Enabler You bought cigarettes for a precocious minor. 6.4%Very rare
- Trout talker You exhausted the fish and yourself. Time is vast and we are ending. 9.4%Very rare
- Smell-o-vision You did it. You sniffed everything. Good job. 12%Very rare
- Blurb herder You learned about all the books in the game. 10.9%Very rare
- Snoopy snooper You checked out every file on Rose's terminal. Even the awkward stuff. 30.5%Rare
- Cruel to be kind Sometimes folks need tough love. Or in your case, all the time. 2.9%Ultra rare
- New habits die easy You snitched to Roger about Joshua smoking. 4.8%Ultra rare
- Act 1 You completed Act 1. 52.5%Common
- Act 2 You completed Act 2. 30.5%Rare
- Act 3 You completed Act 3. 28.8%Rare
- Act 4 You completed Act 4. 26.4%Rare
- Act 5 You completed Act 5. 25.9%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.