Base game
- Did your homework Solve the correct 2nd floor puzzle before the others. 53.6%Common
- The tables have turned Solve the turning tables puzzle in 5 clicks or less. 16.8%Rare
- Procrastinating Complete the 2nd floor's extra puzzles. 34%Rare
- Graduated with horrors Complete the Abandoned School. 53.7%Common
- The Barbarian Unlock the cabinet like a true barbarian. 46.6%Rare
- Poorly kept secret Find the witch hunters' hiding place before it is revealed to you. 28.6%Rare
- Rat Chaser Grab all rats in the room. 55.6%Common
- Forever Cursed Complete the Keep of Lost Souls. 47.5%Rare
- Hunterborn You don't care for money, you are a hunter. 40.5%Rare
- Worst Party Ever No one is even looking at each other. 18.8%Rare
- I AM RICH! Complete the Secret Inheritance. 47.3%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.