Base game
- Fibbage 4: Film Buff Write a lie that's actually the truth during a movie question 1.6%Ultra rare
- Fibbage 4: Crowdsourced Audience earns the highest possible score rank in a game with at least 3 audience members 0.1%Ultra rare
- Fibbage 4: Swiss Army Lie Write a lie that gets picked for both blanks in the final round 43.2%Rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 0.2%Ultra rare
- Roomerang: We Were All Rooting for You! Trigger a Double Elimination 13.1%Very rare
- Roomerang: Catfished! Get every vote in the Quickie Round 7.8%Very rare
- Roomerang: I Made it Nice! Play 3 games in a row with “same players” 0.2%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 5.1%Very rare
- Junktopia: Shrewd Businessfrog Successfully haggle on an item 39.7%Rare
- Junktopia: Extrovert Choose to present your items yourselves 24%Rare
- Junktopia: One Frog's Trash Get at least 4 votes using a mystery item 25.2%Rare
- Junktopia: Crowd Sorcery Audience casts a spell 2.3%Ultra rare
- Nonsensory: Gas Leak Go 25 rounds without a fart 1.6%Ultra rare
- Nonsensory: Circuit Breaker Every player gets the same question exactly right 12.4%Very rare
- Nonsensory: The Confidence of Youth Use Confidence every time in one round 17.4%Rare
- Nonsensory: Smart Cookie Audience earns the highest ranking 0.4%Ultra rare
- Quixort: Show-off Get a perfect sort on the first try during the final round 1%Ultra rare
- Quixort: Human or Machine? Make it through 10 rounds in Quixort Forever 0.3%Ultra rare
- Quixort: Employee of the Month Get a perfect score in normal mode 0.1%Ultra rare
- Quixort: Falling Fast Beat the Jackbox office champ’s time in Quixort Classic or Quixort Forever 0.1%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.