Base game
- My Name is Mayo - The Third! Spend time with the people you love. 90%Common
- Hummm Hit the Mayo 10 times. 99.3%Common
- Moon shake! Earthquakes but not on earth (Hit 50 times!) 98.8%Common
- Oh stop it you! Red-faced (Hit 100 times!) 98.6%Common
- Mighty blader Long time no pee (Hit 500 times!) 97.2%Common
- Rabbits are tough cookies Fluffy on the outside, tough on the inside. (Hit 750 times!) 96.5%Common
- Not funny, didn't laugh. Was that a joke? (Hit this 1500 times!) 95.3%Common
- Extra thick That fact’s a bit dodgy, mate... (Hit 2000 times!) 94.7%Common
- Nose watcher Watchin’ the ol’ snout (Hit 4000 times!) 93%Common
- Crows know what you did... Crows are cute! (Hit 5000 times!) 92.6%Common
- Creamy and tangy , oh my! The secret ingredient that simply does it all! (7000) 92%Common
- Is loneliness my fate? Hit the Mayo 40 times. 99%Common
- Pizza and love. Just me, myself and pizza. (Hit this 115 times) 93.8%Common
- Goth chick! Surprise delivery. (Hit this 75 times) 93.4%Common
- The dark kiss. Order pizza, get the girl. (Hit this 150 times) 93.1%Common
- Are you going to eat that? Down to get lucky! (Hit this 125 times) 92.9%Common
- Is this finally true love? Walk for a pizza dis gal. (Hit this 200 times) 92.7%Common
- A lick of luck! After a deadly stroll. (Hit this 200 times) 92.6%Common
- Hitting a home run! Hitting to 3rd base. (Hit this 300 times) 92.4%Common
- Could it be worse? Memory holed... (Hit this 250 times) 92.3%Common
- It’s itchy now... Alone… yet again. (Hit this 350 times) 92.2%Common
- Dreams were made of that Hit the Mayo 150 times. 98.2%Common
- Quitting the dream AGAIN Disillusioned again (Hit this 75 times) 93.4%Common
- Watching away the hours Trashed dreams (Hit this 200 times) 92.6%Common
- Set on “do not disturb” Fun videos are not fun (Hit this 100 times) 92.4%Common
- Getting influenced? Waiting for a new calling (Hit this 300 times) 92.1%Common
- Start of a new life! Radical new idea (Hit this 150 times) 92%Common
- The video froze up Setting up to the max! (Hit this 300 times) 91.9%Common
- Onto fame and glory! Gaslighted! (Hit this 200 times) 91.8%Common
- Something down my spine Popularity... (Hit this 400 times) 91.7%Common
- Now what...? Unlock all stories. 91.2%Common
- Starting to hear voices, maaan... Cooked up (Hit this 300 times. 97.8%Common
- Pizza time with a goof! Lonely for too long again (Hit this 150 times) 93.4%Common
- Floor meals are the best Ready to mingle (Hit this 200 times) 92.7%Common
- Off to meet the pizza! Special pizza! (Hit this 150 times) 92.4%Common
- Awful lot of talking with no brains Sun be hittin’ differently (Hit this 200 times) 92.2%Common
- Yellow bricked lanes New friend! (Hit this 150 times) 92.1%Common
- I shall take the heart City lookin’ different (Hit this 250 times) 92%Common
- Courage doesn’t always roar Setting up a real party (Hit this 200 times) 91.9%Common
- Wicked itch for pizza Getting the gang together (Hit this 250 times) 91.8%Common
- There’s no place like home? Always had the power (Hit this 300 times) 91.8%Common
- A new start Start the journey 90.6%Common
- First mile down Reach the first mile 90.5%Common
- Storm in the head Reach the second mile 90.4%Common
- High experience Reach the third mile 90.3%Common
- A trip and a half Reach the fourth mile 90.2%Common
- Fun memories Reach the fifth mile 90.2%Common
- Impossibilities Reach the sixth mile 90.1%Common
- Acceptance Reach the seventh mile 90.1%Common
- New perspective Reach the eight mile 90.1%Common
- End of a journey Reach the final mile 90%Common
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.