Base game
- Prized Pie You've learned how to make a pie! 96.2%Common
- Appleseed Acquire 20 points 99.1%Common
- Apple Aware Acquire 100 points 98.7%Common
- Apple Aspiring Acquire 200 points 98.5%Common
- Apple Anatomist Acquire 250 points 98.5%Common
- Apple Appreciator Acquire 300 points 98.4%Common
- Gathering Complete gathering the apples 99.1%Common
- Washing Complete washing the apples 98.6%Common
- Cutting Complete cutting the apples 98.2%Common
- Blending Blend all the apples 97.1%Common
- Dough making Mix the dough 96.8%Common
- Rolling Make the crust 96.8%Common
- Decorating Decorate the pie before putting it into an oven 96.7%Common
- Baking Bake the pie! 96.7%Common
- Start anew Start making the second pie 96.3%Common
- Baking Bad Acquire 350 points 98.3%Common
- Crusty Creator Acquire 400 points 98.1%Common
- Dough Deliverer Acquire 450 points 97.2%Common
- Eager Eater Acquire 500 points 97.2%Common
- Pie Predator Acquire 600 points 97%Common
- Make it stop Stop the blender 98.1%Common
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.