Base game
- I am the monster that breathing men would kill. Unlock all Trophies. 8.3%Very rare
- I'm a mean servant of God. Father D stakes a vampire. 53.6%Common
- Shock shock, horror horror. Molly stakes a vampire. 46.5%Rare
- The blood is the life. Edgar kills a slayer. 56.8%Common
- Stay away from me. Nina kills a slayer. 43%Rare
- There's something out there. Edgar uses his special ability. 53.6%Common
- Silent and deadly. Nina uses her special ability. 40.3%Rare
- Multas per gentes et multa. Father D uses his Crucifix. 49.8%Rare
- You give love a bad name. Shot through the heart. 33.3%Rare
- Abbey expert. Fifteen or more kills, zero deaths. 11.5%Very rare
- Asylum expert. Fifteen or more kills, zero deaths. 10.6%Very rare
- Church expert. Fifteen or more kills, zero deaths. 10.1%Very rare
- LoSt expert. Fifteen or more kills, zero deaths. 9.6%Very rare
- Quaint expert. Fifteen or more kills, zero deaths. 9.3%Very rare
- Retro Quaint expert. Fifteen or more kills, zero deaths. 9%Very rare
- Retro Feint expert. Fifteen or more kills, zero deaths. 8.8%Very rare
- Retro Lynch expert. Fifteen or more kills, zero deaths. 8.8%Very rare
- Retro Castle expert. Fifteen or more kills, zero deaths. 8.7%Very rare
- Retro Cloisters expert. Fifteen or more kills, zero deaths. 8.7%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.