Base game
- Pirate King The Core Trophies of SkullPirates 3%Ultra rare
- Hello, Sharktavia Meet Sharktavia. 54.5%Common
- Breaking the Law Defeat 50 cat policemen. 27%Rare
- Tea Time Defeat 100 teapot policemen. 11.5%Very rare
- Rocket Cat Encounter 10 cat dropships. 23.5%Rare
- Cat in a Teapot Defeat Cat in a Teapot. 57.8%Common
- Break Ye Bones Defeat Billy Boney. 17.6%Rare
- We Are One, We Are All Meet the Fish Cultists. 12.6%Very rare
- Crab Meat Defeat Cave Crab. 12.1%Very rare
- Your Highness Meet the Queen. 10.5%Very rare
- Queen's Riches Gather 10000 gold coins. 6.4%Very rare
- Voyage Destination Complete the game. 9.5%Very rare
- Yer Bounties Complete 10 bounties. 4.3%Ultra rare
- Collector Obtain 30 gear items. 3.7%Ultra rare
- Lion Mech Defeat Lion Mech. 14.2%Very rare
- Greedy Cats Finish the Bank level. 13.6%Very rare
- Tripod Plotting Defeat Tripod. 27.6%Rare
- Famine's Folly Complete Famine's Folly 5 times. 3.9%Ultra rare
- King of the SkullPirates Obtain the Crown hat item. 5%Ultra rare
- Whaled Up Defeat Mecha Whale. 4.5%Ultra rare
- Pirate Love Obtain 10 heart containers. 4.1%Ultra rare
- Mech Warrior Defeat Mech. 3.7%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.