Base game
- Detective In The Making Play your first game 88.4%Common
- The Plot Thickens... Uncover your first Clue 58.7%Common
- Online Sleuth Play 5 Online Multiplayer Games 9.9%Very rare
- A Killer Among Us Play an Online with Friends Game 27%Rare
- Element of Surprise Play 5 Clue Cards Games 19.6%Rare
- Deduction Master Play 5 Ultimate Detective Games 12.3%Very rare
- Nobody Suspects The Inquisitor! Ask 3 Key Question 24.6%Rare
- Old School Detective Play a game with the Clue Sheet set to Manual 4.3%Ultra rare
- Appearances Matter Play a game with an alternative customization item equipped 9.9%Very rare
- A Victorious Token Win a game with an alternative Token equipped 10.3%Very rare
- A Tough Challenge Win a Single Player game in Hard difficulty 10.4%Very rare
- Seasoned Detective Win 20 games 10.4%Very rare
- House Secrets Play 5 games at the Tudor Mansion 46.8%Rare
- A Thorough Investigation Complete the (Tudor Mansion) Case File 5.3%Very rare
BlackAdder Trophies
DLC- A Vacation Gone Wrong Complete the (Black Adder Resort) Case File 2.4%Ultra rare
- Mysterious Island Play 5 games at the Black Adder Resort 13.2%Very rare
Whispering Pines Retreat Trophies
DLC- Playing God Complete the Whispering Pines Retreat Case File 1.8%Ultra rare
- Unnerving Retreat Play 5 games at the Whispering Pines Retreat 8.4%Very rare
Polar Research Station Trophies
DLC- The Things In The Cold Complete the (Polar Research Station) Case File 1.5%Ultra rare
- Secluded Station Play 5 games at the Polar Research Station 6.2%Very rare
Noir Mansion Trophies
DLC- The City Never Sleeps Complete the (Noir Mansion) Case File 0.7%Ultra rare
- Silent Mansion Play 5 games at the Noir Mansion 2.5%Ultra rare
Painted Red Gallery Trophies
DLC- Every Masterpiece Hides a Secret Complete the (Painted Red Gallery) Case File 0.1%Ultra rare
- A Regular at the Exhibition Play 5 games at the Painted Red Gallery 0.1%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.