Base game
- The Lamp Collect the Lamp at the beginning of the game 86.5%Common
- The Axe Collect the Axe from the old shack 54%Common
- The Lodge Key Collect the lodge key from the tent 61.7%Common
- The Dagger 1 Collect the ceremonial dagger 39.8%Rare
- The Dagger 2 Collect the ceremonial dagger 42.2%Rare
- The Dagger 3 Collect the ceremonial dagger 52.4%Common
- The Dagger 4 Collect the ceremonial dagger 39.4%Rare
- The Dagger 5 Collect the ceremonial dagger 56.5%Common
- The Flashlight Collect the flashlight inside of the first house 70.3%Common
- The Mask Collect the mask of the witch 48.3%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.