Base game
- I Am the Nightmare Unlock all trophies in Alone in the Dark: The New Nightmare (2001). 1.3%Ultra rare
- Sewage Serpent Defeat the Phocomelus in the Basement Pipeworks. 10.6%Very rare
- Toasted Bed Tentacles Defeat the monster in the Manor Second Floor West Bedroom. 4.3%Ultra rare
- Dark-Winged Menace Defeat the Procuraptor in the Manor Library. 3.6%Ultra rare
- The Nightmare's Linchpin Defeat Alan Morton in the World of Darkness Necropolis. 2.9%Ultra rare
- Shade of the Night Defeat Phocomelus in Lucy's Bedroom. 8.5%Very rare
- A Father No More Defeat Howard Morton in the Manor Library. 2.2%Ultra rare
- Shocking Defeat Defeat Howard Morton in the Lightning Conductor Room. 2%Ultra rare
- Morton's Toll Defeat Obed Morton in the World of Darkness Columns. 1.7%Ultra rare
- Condemned Manor Escape the Manor as Carnby. 3.4%Ultra rare
- Perforated Escape Escape the Fort as Aline. 2%Ultra rare
- Closing the Case Escape Shadow Island as Carnby. 2.9%Ultra rare
- Conquering the Nightmare Escape Shadow Island as Aline. 1.9%Ultra rare
- Anticoalt's Bison Collect the Abkanis Statue of Anticoalt. 4.7%Ultra rare
- Hemicles's Bull Collect the Indian Statue of Hemicles. 3.2%Ultra rare
- Ouphenos's Bear Collect the Indian Statue of Ouphenos. 3%Ultra rare
- Gilamesh's Snake Collect the Indian Statue of Gilamesh. 2%Ultra rare
- Heliopaner's Fish Collect the Indian Statue of Heliopaner. 2%Ultra rare
- Hecatonchires's Eagle Collect the Indian Statue of Hecatonchires. 1.9%Ultra rare
- Classic Six-Shooter Collect the Revolver. 3.6%Ultra rare
- For Three Times the Fun! Collect the Triple-Barreled Gun. 9.3%Very rare
- Potato Gun Collect the Grenade Launcher. 7.2%Very rare
- Packs a Punch Collect the Rocket Launcher Pistol. 4.6%Ultra rare
- Gas It Up Collect the Plasma Cannon. 3.8%Ultra rare
- Slow but Deadly Collect the Photoelectric Pulsar. 3.2%Ultra rare
- The Nightmare's Nightmare Collect the Lightning Gun. 3.3%Ultra rare
- You Fool! Give the mirror to Judas De Certo. 2.5%Ultra rare
- Not My First Rodeo As Carnby, enter the Basement Pipeworks without firing your weapon. 2.7%Ultra rare
- Detective's Insight As Carnby, investigate 25 objects. 7.9%Very rare
- Thorough Investigation As Carnby, enter every possible room in the Manor, and unlock all possible doors. 3%Ultra rare
- Could It Be True? As Aline, consult the Black & White Photograph. 3.1%Ultra rare
- This Thing's Useless! As Aline, attempt to reload the Revolver after depleting all ammo for it. 2.5%Ultra rare
- Don't Leave a Gal Hanging As Aline, use the Walkie-Talkie in 10 unique rooms. 2.4%Ultra rare
- Well Documented Examine 15 unique documents across both playthroughs. 1.5%Ultra rare
- Let's Make a Documentary Examine 30 unique documents across both playthroughs. 1.3%Ultra rare
- Fear Me, for I Am Your End Defeat 50 monsters across both playthroughs. 3.9%Ultra rare
- Shadow Hunter Defeat one of each type of common monster across both playthroughs. 3.2%Ultra rare
- Effective Arsenal Defeat a monster using every weapon in the game. 1.7%Ultra rare
- Tactical Reload Reload your weapon using the Reload option in the Weapons menu. 15.1%Rare
- Try Not to Waste Those! Use a First Aid Kit when your life bar displays a Fine status. 4%Ultra rare
- Afraid of the Dark Turn on 10 light switches throughout the Manor. 5.4%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.









































