Base game
- The Pirate King Collect all Trophies 0.7%Ultra rare
- Betrayed Complete the Prologue on any tier 71.9%Common
- A Rogue Reborn Complete Act I on any tier 22.6%Rare
- Heart of Glass Complete Act II on any tier 13%Very rare
- Plunder and Ruin! Complete Act III on any tier 9.5%Very rare
- Rising Tide Defeat Blackbone's final form on difficulty level Heroic III or higher. 3%Ultra rare
- An Eye for an Eye! Defeat the Blackbone's final form on difficulty level Ultimate V or higher. 1.5%Ultra rare
- Terror of the Seas! Defeat the Blackbone's final form on difficulty level Ultimate IX. 0.8%Ultra rare
- The Legendary Captain Cutter Reach maximum Cutter level 2.2%Ultra rare
- He's Flippin' Brilliant! Reach the maximum Grappler level 1.6%Ultra rare
- Masterchef Reach the maximum Cook level 2.2%Ultra rare
- Knives Out! Reach the maximum Backstabber level 1.5%Ultra rare
- Leave It To Cleaver! Reach the maximum Cleaver level 1.4%Ultra rare
- Dead shot Reach the maximum Musketeer level 1.5%Ultra rare
- That's the Spear-it! Reach the maximum Spearmaiden level 1.8%Ultra rare
- Priority Shipping Buy all Ship upgrades 12.2%Very rare
- Quartermaster Buy all Equipment upgrades 12.1%Very rare
- All Decked Out Buy all Crew upgrades 5.7%Very rare
- Rise of the Sea Shepherd Buy all Sea Monsters upgrades 4.9%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.

























