Base game
- Platinum Prestidigitator Collect All Trophies 0.1%Ultra rare
- Golem Town Champion Defeat Iron Golem in Golem Tower 12.1%Very rare
- Undead Stalker Defeat 50 Undead 16.6%Rare
- Undead Hunter Defeat 100 Undead 9.8%Very rare
- Undead Conqueror Defeat 500 Undead 2.4%Ultra rare
- Novice Gardener Achieve Gardening Rank 1 7.4%Very rare
- Apprentice Gardener Achieve Gardening Rank 3 2.8%Ultra rare
- Intermediate Gardener Achieve Gardening Rank 5 2.3%Ultra rare
- Beastmoon Hunter Finish 1 Match 1.2%Ultra rare
- Beastmoon Warrior Finish 25 Matches 0.1%Ultra rare
- Maximal Mayhemist Win 10 Beastmoon Mayhem matches 0.1%Ultra rare
- Novice Angler Achieve Fishing Rank 1 11.3%Very rare
- Apprentice Angler Achieve Fishing Rank 3 5.3%Very rare
- Catch of the Day Catch 1 Small Fry Fish 3.7%Ultra rare
- Fishy Business Catch 10 unique fish 4%Ultra rare
- Elixir Vitae Restore 1,000,000 Health or more using a single spell 0.1%Ultra rare
- One in a Million Deal over 1,000,000 Damage or more using a single spell 0.3%Ultra rare
- Rookie Pet Owner Own 10 unique pets 6.9%Very rare
- Proud Pet Owner Own 50 unique pets 1%Ultra rare
- Gobbler Drop Hotshot Win Gobbler Drop 25 times 0.5%Ultra rare
- Grumpy Gobbler Hotshot Win Grumpy Gobbler 25 times 1.2%Ultra rare
- Maze Game Hotshot Win Maze Game 25 times 0.6%Ultra rare
- Way of the Ninja Pig Hotshot Win Way of the Ninja Pig 25 times 0.2%Ultra rare
- Dance Game Hotshot Win Dance Game 25 times 2.6%Ultra rare
- Hero of Unicorn Way Complete all quests in Unicorn Way (excluding Yellow Brick Road and Not in Kansas Anymore) 21%Rare
- Three Streets Savior Complete all quests in Cyclops Lane, Triton Avenue, and Firecat Alley 5.2%Very rare
- Wizard City Protector Defeat Lord Nightshade in Stormdrain Tower 16.9%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.