Base game
- The guardian of the law Get all other trophies 49.2%Rare
- Everything is just beginning Complete the level with training 92.1%Common
- My stop Free the train from bandits 74.2%Common
- You are the law here! Kill 100 bandits 77.7%Common
- No one can hide Kill 150 bandits 72.8%Common
- Wild West Thunderstorm Kill 200 bandits 69.4%Common
- A big catch Complete contract #7 and get a $1,000 reward 71%Common
- What time is it? Pick up 10 of any watches 82.9%Common
- Leather hat lover Pick up 15 leather hats 75.3%Common
- A new toy Buy a TEYLER revolver at a gun store 57%Common
- Let's start the fun Buy a DUBBY double-barreled shotgun at a gun store 52%Common
- The wind in your face Complete 4 horse contracts 53.1%Common
- The main thing is not to blow up… Complete 2 Dynamite Wagon defense contracts 67.8%Common
- Great deal Sell 25 items to the banker 74.7%Common
- To become a better person Buy any 3 skills from the skill seller 61.4%Common
- The Great Liberator Release 30 hostages 60.9%Common
- Steel Niko Defeat Nico's boss 50%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.
