Base game
- Final Treasure Unlock all other Trophies. 10.8%Very rare
- Teache's Treasure Merge 150 treasures. 83.7%Common
- Newgate's Treasure Merge 300 treasures. 75.5%Common
- Kid's Treasure Merge 1000 treasures. 10.8%Very rare
- Once Piece Merge 2000 treasures. 44.3%Rare
- X Marks The Spot Merge into Treasure Chest. 52.4%Common
- Never Enough Achieve full cycle. 38.9%Rare
- Bomba-man Use BOMB spell. 83.7%Common
- Volcano Use ERUPTION spell. 85.5%Common
- Seance Use SPECTER spell. 85.5%Common
- Oyster Use PEARL spell. 85.9%Common
- Curse Bearer Use RUBY CURSE spell. 86.4%Common
- Spellslinger Learn all the spells. 67.4%Common
- Dropping the Ballast Destroy a stone before it lands. 43.8%Rare
- Hard boiled Stones Destroy 3 stones using ERUPTION. 68.7%Common
- Break the Curse Throw cursed treasure out of screen. 54.7%Common
- Cursed Curse Merge 2 cursed treasures with each other. 59.7%Common
- Pearl Jam Merge 2 pearls with each other. 26.6%Rare
- Dead Weight Destroy 10 stones. 80.5%Common
- Sunken Ship Destroy 100 stones. 47.9%Rare
- Matey Unlock your first accessory. 67.8%Common
- Sailor Unlock 4 accessories. 62.4%Common
- Pirate Unlock 8 accessories. 58.3%Common
- Corsair Unlock 16 accessories. 52.9%Common
- Captain Unlock 32 accessories. 46.1%Rare
- Drunken Sailor Unlock Pirate Cat. 32.5%Rare
- School Is In Collect all fishes. 37.1%Rare
- Shark Tank Collect all sharks. 30.7%Rare
- Arctic Ocean Collect all penguins. 33%Rare
- Guinea Pig Collect all pigs. 31.2%Rare
- New Bounty Change starting title. 53.3%Common
- Blinged Out Equip accessories on all slots. 43.4%Rare
- Like a Rat Abandon the sinking ship. 47%Rare
- Get a Crew Find a crewmate. 46.1%Rare
- Punkrocker Maybe that's the real punk rock. 23%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.