Base game
- Completionist Unlock all trophies 2.5%Ultra rare
- Well, Lookee Here! Find a secret 79.4%Common
- Croaked Quack Defeat Dr. Death 33.3%Rare
- Il Buono Complete the single player campaign on Good difficulty or higher 30%Rare
- How the West Was Won Complete Civil War 16.8%Rare
- Dyin' ain't much of a living, boy Complete Wharf Town 12.2%Very rare
- El Mariscal Complete Villa 13.6%Very rare
- Slippin' and Slidin' Complete Ice Caves 12.1%Very rare
- True Grit Finish a level with less than 1 health 10.5%Very rare
- You're My Favorite Reach Deputy Rank in Marshal Training 15.2%Rare
- Wanted Dead or Alive Kill all Outlaws in Marshal Training 5.4%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 15.3%Rare
- Il Brutto Complete the single player campaign on Bad difficulty or higher 13.5%Very rare
- Courageous, Loyal, and above all, Honest Reach Sheriff Rank in Marshal Training 14.5%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 12.6%Very rare
- Marshal, and Detective Too Find all secrets in Marshal Training 3.7%Ultra rare
- For a Few Secrets More Find all secrets in Handful of Missions 2.9%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 18.9%Rare
- Semi Portable, Fully Loaded Acquire The Ash.Co Gatling Gun 39.9%Rare
- Get Three Coffins Ready... Kill 3 people with a single bundle of dynamite 28%Rare
- Il Cattivo Complete the single player campaign on Ugly difficulty 6.5%Very rare
- Good Cop Capture all Outlaws in Marshal Training 4.5%Ultra rare
- Them Thar Hills Find all the gold in Marshal Training 3%Ultra rare
- The Searcher Find all secrets in the single player campaign 3.5%Ultra rare
- Wear the Badge Again Reach Marshal Rank in Marshal Training 14%Very rare
- If Ya Can't Take It Give Dynamite Dick a Taste of His Own Medicine 7.2%Very rare
- A Man Can Get Too Ambitious Defeat Bob Graham 30%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.



























