Base game
- Hastur Earn all trophies 27%Rare
- Once Isn't Enough Do not wake up ICEY 45.1%Rare
- Pitfalls Do not activate the photon bridge and jump 3 times into the ravine 49.4%Rare
- Restart, Restart Keep trying to go left in the "extra area" 35.8%Rare
- Junk Jumper Jump into sewage 3 times 53.3%Common
- God's 9 Billion Names Learn the name of God 30.3%Rare
- Trophy Addict Finish the story in the "Totally Empty Room" 36.5%Rare
- Waiting for Nothing Wait for a few minutes in the "Totally Empty Room" 36.6%Rare
- Bronze Trophy Earn a bronze trophy in the "Totally Empty Room" 36.5%Rare
- Silver Trophy Earn a silver trophy in the "Totally Empty Room" 36.5%Rare
- Buy Another Copy! Witness secrets of development in the "Archive Room" 55.1%Common
- Gate Crasher Ignore the narrator and enter Emberville before the gate closes 41.4%Rare
- Black Star Rises And in the dark of night, the unfathomable Black Star rises 38%Rare
- People Are Pigs Select "Not Ready" before the final battle 32.7%Rare
- SHIO Enter level "Shio" 42.3%Rare
- CEO and Miss Perfect Earn sponsorship for the game 31.2%Rare
- ICEY, UCEY Discover the truth of ICEY's birth 42.4%Rare
- And the Next Song is...? Destroy the background music player 30.2%Rare
- The Abyss Watches Back Confront the Yellow King in the monitor room 41.8%Rare
- "Outside" Fire Encourage the narrator to meet the tip of a bullet 31.9%Rare
- True Love Do not kill Dahal's self which lives within Trinity 35.5%Rare
- Modern Day Pandora's Box Break open Pandora's box 35.3%Rare
- To Meet You Again Witness the birth of ICEY's self-awareness 27.7%Rare
- Follow the Leader Enter the real "game" with the narrator 91%Common
- Trinity's Chains Defeat Trinity Trinity could not stop this cycle, nor can she ever stop the wheel of reincarnation from spinning. 95.7%Common
- Gorger's Apathy Defeat Gorger Gorger was a simple resident of Ultimopolis that sacrificed himself to Judas without regret... or any other feelings. 56.6%Common
- Thor's Loyalty Defeat Thor Thor understood Judas' ultimate goal, and paid the ultimate price of splitting his self to serve Judas. 58.3%Common
- Parker's Lost Heart Defeat Parker Parker, betrayed by Judas, retreated with no conscience to the dark corners of the metro. 56.5%Common
- Carlos' Ambitions Defeat Carlos Carlos was fed up with the constant sacrifice of his self in each reincarnation. His solution? Kill and replace the Chosen One. 50.6%Common
- Jack's Faith Defeat Jack While Jack's faith is unwavering, being banished to the furthest corner of the world left him unable to even come close to the Chosen One. 41.8%Rare
- Ideon's Resignation Defeat Ideon Ideon's self was slowly destroyed through the process of never-ending reincarnation, leaving him even more vulnerable to Judas' manipulation. 42.2%Rare
- Dahal's Pain Defeat Dahal Only in a virtual world is such a thing possible... To mix two beings' memories... Because of this, Dahal short-circuited. 37%Rare
- Trinity's Self Defeat Trinity Even after her memories were mixed with another's, Trinity still tried to prevent the birth of the Chosen One. That was, of course, futile. 33.9%Rare
- Judas' Repentance Defeat Judas Judas had long ago given up his struggle. As he ascended the Clock Tower, the Black Star rose once more. 38.1%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.