Base game
- Bermuda Hero Collect all other trophies. 0.6%Ultra rare
- Adventurer Successfully complete the tutorial island. 58.6%Common
- Skipper Skip the tutorial island. 23.8%Rare
- Chopper Find the machete on the tutorial island. 95.4%Common
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 26.5%Rare
- Survivor Get revived 50 times by crew members. 0.7%Ultra rare
- Deathwish Die 50 times. 1%Ultra rare
- Captain Recruit 100 crew members. 1%Ultra rare
- Party Leader Lead a full party of 4 crew members. 2.1%Ultra rare
- Guardian Angels Lead a full party of 4 crew members, each with the revive ability and active halos. 1.2%Ultra rare
- Tycoon Collect 10,000 gold. 1.3%Ultra rare
- Veteran Collect 50,000 XP. 1.6%Ultra rare
- Carpenter Order a crew member with the carpenter ability to repair a bridge. 69.8%Common
- Miner Order a crew member with the miner ability to excavate a dig spot. 6%Very rare
- Lock Smith Order a crew member with the locksmith ability to open a chest. 61.9%Common
- Cartographer Reveal 1000 island regions on the map. 0.8%Ultra rare
- Technician Use 100 items. 0.9%Ultra rare
- Botanist Find and interact with a healing tree. 56.1%Common
- Healer Interact with a healing tree 50 times. 1.4%Ultra rare
- Marauder Kill 3000 enemies. 0.9%Ultra rare
- Spin Doctor Kill 100 enemies using the spin attack. 1.1%Ultra rare
- Dashing Kill 100 enemies using the dash attack. 1%Ultra rare
- Gunslinger Kill 25 enemies using guns. 0.8%Ultra rare
- Sapper Kill 50 enemies using bombs. 0.8%Ultra rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 9%Very rare
- Secret trophy Its name and description stay hidden until you earn it. 0.7%Ultra rare
- Berserker Kill 10 enemies while under the effect of adrenaline. 0.9%Ultra rare
- Vandal Destroy 5000 barrels and crates. 0.8%Ultra rare
- Bushwhacker Destroy 5000 bushes. 1.2%Ultra rare
- Completionist Unlock all player skills and ship upgrades in a single play through. 1.1%Ultra rare
- Hardy Unlock the maximum health upgrade. 1.7%Ultra rare
- Moxie Unlock the maximum stamina upgrade. 1.4%Ultra rare
- Jungle Explorer Successfully complete the jungle zone. 8.9%Very rare
- Desert Explorer Successfully complete the desert zone. 2.6%Ultra rare
- Swamp Explorer Successfully complete the swamp zone. 1.3%Ultra rare
- Snow Explorer Successfully complete the snow zone. 1.1%Ultra rare
- Escapist Successfully escape the Bermuda Triangle. 0.9%Ultra rare
- Speed Demon Complete the game in under 2 hours without warping. 0.6%Ultra rare
- Army of One Complete the game without recruiting any crew members. 0.6%Ultra rare
- Purist Complete the game without unlocking any player skills or ship upgrades. 0.6%Ultra rare
- Traditionalist Complete the game without using any items. 0.6%Ultra rare
- Relic Hunter Collect and deliver 100 tablets to the map table. 1.2%Ultra rare
- High Roller Get a combined total of 10 or more across 3 tablets. 9.3%Very rare
- Archaeologist Collect 3 tablets on a single island. 18.8%Rare
- Baiter Trigger 100 traps. 1%Ultra rare
- Treasure Hunter Collect all 18 pieces of treasure. 0.8%Ultra rare
- Savior Rescue 10 crew members using the life ring ship upgrade. 0.7%Ultra rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.