Base game
- Madden NFL 11 Master Congratulations on earning every Madden NFL 11 trophy! 0.5%Ultra rare
- Very Special Teams Return 2 kicks for touchdowns in one game with one player (no OTP) 17.5%Rare
- Butterfingers Force 3 fumbles in a game (no OTP) 44.1%Rare
- Man Dozer Rush for 50 yards after the first hit in one game (no OTP) 54.9%Common
- He's Got All Day Stay in the pocket for 10 seconds (no OTP) 4.2%Ultra rare
- Did I Break It? Win a game by at least 59 points (max qtr. len. 7 min, no OTP) 22.3%Rare
- Winning Isn't Everything Catch 21 passes in a game with one player (no OTP) 6.1%Very rare
- Old Spice Swagger Return Return a punt for a touchdown (no OTP) 36.8%Rare
- Comeback Kids Win after being behind in the last 2 min of the game (min qtr. len. 3 min, no OTP) 41.8%Rare
- No Offense Intercept 5 passes in a game (no OTP) 28.2%Rare
- Fantasy Freak Rush for over 200 yards in a game with one player (no OTP) 36%Rare
- Nano Tackle the QB before he can hand the ball off (no OTP) 31.5%Rare
- Elusive Man Break 5 tackles in a game with one player (no OTP) 40.4%Rare
- Thanks For Coming Play the Pro Bowl (Franchise Mode) 6%Very rare
- Perfect Game Have a perfect passer rating in a game (no OTP) 33.1%Rare
- Home Run Break an 80+ yard touchdown run (no OTP) 40.1%Rare
- Old Spice Swagger Pick 6 Intercept a pass and return it for a touchdown (no OTP) 66.6%Common
- YACtastic Have over 100 YAC in one game (no OTP) 47.8%Rare
- Pick Up 6 Win a Fight for the Fumble in the end zone for a TD (no OTP) 3.9%Ultra rare
- Deadly Accurate Have a 92% or higher completion percentage in a game (min. 20 attempts, no OTP) 4.2%Ultra rare
- Laces Out Kick a 60+ yard Field Goal (no OTP) 3.9%Ultra rare
- Madden Moments Complete the "Super Bowl Sunday" Madden Moment 1.5%Ultra rare
- Defensive Dominance Hold your opponent to under 100 yards of offense (min qtr. len. 5 min, no OTP) 35.9%Rare
- Sack Master Record 5 sacks in a game with one player (no OTP) 11.4%Very rare
- Master Strategist Create a Game Plan 7.6%Very rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.