Base game
- Madden NFL 12 Master Congratulations on earning every Madden NFL 12 trophy! 0.3%Ultra rare
- Put Da Team On My Back Catch a 99 yard TD pass with Greg Jennings (No OTP or co-op) 1.6%Ultra rare
- Leon Washington Award Return 2+ kicks for touchdowns in one game with one player (No OTP or co-op) 7.6%Very rare
- Reggie Wayne Award Catch 14+ passes in one game with one player (No OTP or co-op) 14.3%Very rare
- Matt Schaub Award Pass for 497+ yards in one game with one player (No OTP or co-op) 23%Rare
- Oakland Raiders Award Win by 45 points or more (No OTP or co-op) 27%Rare
- Arian Foster Award Rush for 231+ yards in a game with one player (No OTP or co-op) 38.8%Rare
- Dan Carpenter Award Kick a 60+ yard FG (No OTP or co-op) 3.9%Ultra rare
- DeAngelo Hall Award Intercept 4+ passes in one game (No OTP or co-op) 49.3%Rare
- Adrian Peterson Award Score on an 80+ yard TD run (No OTP or co-op) 52.3%Common
- Kenny Britt Award Gain 225+ yards receiving with one player (No OTP or co-op) 35%Rare
- San Diego Chargers Award Hold your opponent to under 67 yds of total offense (minimum 5 min. qtr., no OTP or co-op) 45.5%Rare
- Mario Manningham Award Catch a 92+ yard TD pass (No OTP or co-op) 28.4%Rare
- Santonio Holmes Award Catch a game winning TD pass in OT (No OTP or co-op) 15.7%Rare
- Rob Gronkowski Award Catch 3+ TD passes with a TE in a game (No OTP or co-op) 20.6%Rare
- New York Giants Award Record 10+ sacks as a team in one game (No OTP or co-op) 20.7%Rare
- Darren McFadden Award Score 4+ rushing TDs in a single game (No OTP or co-op) 43.4%Rare
- Michael Vick Award Rush for 130+ yards with your QB (No OTP or co-op) 10.6%Very rare
- DeSean Jackson Award Return a punt for a TD (No OTP or co-op) 11.8%Very rare
- Tim Tebow Award Score a 40+ yard TD run with a QB (No OTP or co-op) 15.3%Rare
- Bryan McCann Award Return an interception 100+ yards (No OTP or co-op) 18.3%Rare
- Happy 20th EA SPORTS! Score 20 points in a game (No OTP or co-op) 79.3%Common
- Peyton Hillis Award Rush for 184+ yards in one game with Peyton Hillis (No OTP or co-op) 3.8%Ultra rare
- David Bowens Award Have 2 pick 6's in the same game (No OTP or co-op) 30.3%Rare
- Tom Brady Award Have a passer rating of 149+ in a game (No OTP or co-op) 44.3%Rare
- Jahvid Best Award Gain 154+ yards receiving with Jahvid Best (No OTP or co-op) 1.4%Ultra rare
- New York Jets Award Gain over 100+ yards rushing with 2 RBs in the same game (No OTP or co-op) 18.6%Rare
- Hey, Can I Talk to You? User complete one season's final cut day in Franchise Mode 12.1%Very rare
- Winning Win a FA bidding in Franchise Mode 14.9%Very rare
- The Next Big Thing Create an NFL Superstar 34.8%Rare
- We're Talking About Practice Complete a practice in Superstar Mode 36.9%Rare
- This One is Easy Create a MUT team 16.2%Rare
- This One is Hard Build an 80 rated MUT team 2.4%Ultra rare
- Wheel and Deal Make a MUT Trade 1.5%Ultra rare
- Ultimate Veteran Complete 10 MUT Games 2.7%Ultra rare
- MUT Maniac Complete 20 MUT Games 1.7%Ultra rare
- Verizon Scoreboard Overload Score 50 points in one game (No OTP or co-op) 42.4%Rare
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.